Drive Thru
Index

Tim Hortons menu prices, 1989 Seneca St, Buffalo, NY

$$$$$ About average for a Tim Hortons in the US

#393of 678Tim Hortons in the US
#197of 265in New York
#23of 26in Buffalo
#73of 88within 10 mi

Rank by the price of the same basket of items: #1 is the cheapest Tim Hortons.

Cheapest Tim Hortons within 10 mi

Every restaurant of the brand within that distance, cheapest first by the same basket of items. Distances are in a straight line.

RankRestaurantDistanceMedium Original BlendBasketDifference
12001 Main StBuffalo, NY5.2 mi$1.90$8.63−$4.53
25600 Mckinley PkwyHamburg, NY8.4 mi$1.90$8.63−$4.53
3University AT Buffalo (north CAmherst, NY10.0 mi$1.90$8.63−$4.53
42220 Southwestern BlvdWest Seneca, NY5.6 mi$2.59$12.36−$0.80
5350 Langner RdWest Seneca, NY2.4 mi$2.69$12.56−$0.60
63205 Orchard Park RDOrchard Park, NY5.1 mi$2.69$12.56−$0.60
74301 Genesee StCheektowaga, NY6.8 mi$2.65$12.62−$0.54
81060 Wehrle DrWilliamsville, NY7.3 mi$2.65$12.62−$0.54
95140 Main StWilliamsville, NY7.6 mi$2.65$12.62−$0.54
106125 Main StWilliamsville, NY8.7 mi$2.65$12.62−$0.54
115225 Sheridan DrWilliamsville, NY9.1 mi$2.65$12.62−$0.54
12870 Maple RdWilliamsville, NY9.7 mi$2.65$12.62−$0.54
131176 South Park AvenueBuffalo, NY1.2 mi$2.59$12.66−$0.50
142530 Hamburg Tpke Apt Rt5Lackawanna, NY3.3 mi$2.59$12.66−$0.50
152080 Abbott RdBuffalo, NY3.4 mi$2.59$12.66−$0.50
161 Scott StreetBuffalo, NY3.6 mi$2.59$12.66−$0.50
173638 S Park AveBlasdell, NY3.9 mi$2.59$12.66−$0.50
18380 Niagara StBuffalo, NY4.6 mi$2.59$12.66−$0.50
192137 Transit RdElma, NY6.2 mi$2.59$12.66−$0.50
204066 Lake Shore RdHamburg, NY6.2 mi$2.59$12.66−$0.50
731989 Seneca StBuffalo, NY this restaurant0.0 mi$2.59$13.16—

1989 Seneca St, Buffalo, NY 14210-2323. See it on the map

Where this restaurant sits among every Tim Hortons in the US

Its basket is cheaper than at 39% of the 678 Tim Hortons restaurants in the US.

01302595$8.00317$10.0084259$12.00122$14.0021$16.002$18.00Typical: $12.87This restaurant: $13.16Number of Tim Hortons restaurants by basket price, in $1.00 steps

Full menu with prices (247 items)

Pickup prices from the Tim Hortons app, checked 2026-11-17. Items linked to their own page show how that price compares across the US.

ItemPickup
Other
Apple Fritter$1.79
Avocado Toast$4.49
Bacon Bagel B.e.l.t$5.69
Bacon Bagel Breakfast Sandwich$5.19
Bacon Egg White & Swiss Wrap$4.89
Bacon Farmer's Breakfast Wrap$5.89
Bacon Grilled Breakfast Wrap$4.69
Bacon Maple Waffle Breakfast Sandwich$5.49
Bacon Wrap Snacker$2.79
Bacon, Egg & Cheese Breakfast Sandwich$4.59
Bacon, Egg and Cheese English Muffin$4.49
Biscoff Croissant$3.19
Blueberry Bagel$2.29
Boston Cream$1.79
Bottled Apple Juice$2.49
Bottled Orange Juice$2.49
Bottled Water$2.29
Buffalo Bacon Farmer's Wrap$6.19
Buffalo Football Timbit$0.60
Buffalo Mug$9.99
Buffalo Sausage Farmer's Wrap$6.19
Bulk Onion & Chive Cream Cheese$5.99
Bulk Strawberry Cream Cheese$5.99
Chocolate Chip Muffin$2.49
Chocolate Chunk Cookie$2.19
Chocolate Dip$1.79
Chocolate Glazed$1.79
Chocolate Glazed Timbit$0.60
Chocolate Milk$2.29
Cinnamon Coffee Cake Donut$1.79
Cinnamon Raisin Bagel$2.29
Classic Bagels Half Dozen$10.99
Cookies Dozen$18.99
Cookies Half Dozen$9.99
Dark Roast Blend Coffee Take 12$23.99
Decaf Blend Coffee Take 12$23.99
Detroit Cold Cup$14.99
Detroit Mug$9.99
Donuts Dozen$16.99
Donuts Half Dozen$8.99
Double Bacon - Double Stacked Breakfast Wrap$5.99
Double Bacon - Double Stacked Farmer's Breakfast Wrap$6.89
Double Sausage - Double Stacked Breakfast Wrap$5.99
Double Sausage - Double Stacked Farmer's Breakfast Wrap$6.89
Egg & Cheese Bagel B.e.l.t$5.29
Egg & Cheese Bagel Breakfast Sandwich$4.49
Egg & Cheese Egg White & Swiss Wrap$4.29
Egg & Cheese Farmer's Breakfast Wrap$5.59
Egg & Cheese Grilled Breakfast Wrap$4.19
Egg & Cheese Maple Waffle Breakfast Sandwich$5.09
Egg & Cheese Wrap Snacker$2.49
Egg and Cheese English Muffin$3.99
Everything Bagel$2.29
Extra Large Specialty Tea$3.19
Extra Large Coffee Mocha$3.69
Extra Large Dark Roast Coffee$3.19
Extra Large Decaf Coffee$3.19
Extra Large French Vanilla$3.69
Extra Large Hot Chocolate$3.69
Extra Large Original Blend Coffee$3.19
Extra Large Steeped Tea$3.19
French Vanilla Take 12$25.99
Gingerbread Ornament$9.99
Gingerbread Platter$7.99
Hashbrown$1.89
Holiday Birthday Cake Timbit$0.60
Holiday Sugar Cookie$2.19
Holiday Vanilla Dip Donut$1.79
Honey Cruller$1.79
Honey Dip$1.79
Honey Dip Timbit$0.60
Hot Chocolate Take 12$24.99
Hot Cocoa Crumble Muffin$2.49
Large Americano$4.09
Large Caramel Iced Capp$5.79
Large Chai Protein Latte$6.19
Large Coffee Mocha$3.49
Large Cookie Butter Iced Capp$5.89
Large Dark Roast Coffee$2.89
Large Decaf Coffee$2.89
Large French Vanilla$3.49
Large Half & Half Lemonade Iced Tea$3.39
Large Hot Chocolate$3.49
Large Iced Capp$4.89
Large Iced Capp Light$4.89
Large Iced Caramel Coffee$4.49
Large Iced Chai Latte$4.89
Large Iced Chai Protein Latte$5.99
Large Iced Coffee Original$3.99
Large Iced Flavored Chai Protein Latte$6.19
Large Iced Flavored Protein Matcha Latte$6.29
Large Iced Lemonade$3.49
Large Iced Matcha Latte$5.09
Large Iced Matcha Protein Latte$5.89
Large Iced Mocha Coffee$4.49
Large Iced Vanilla Almond Coffee$4.69
Large Iced Vanilla Chai Latte$5.49
Large Iced Vanilla Coffee$4.49
Large Matcha Latte$4.89
Large Mocha Iced Capp$5.69
Large Oreo Iced Capp$5.69
Large Original Blend Coffee$2.89
Large Specialty Tea$2.89
Large Steeped Tea$2.89
Large Strawberry Lemonade$4.29
Large Strawberry Watermelon Kiwi Coconut Refresher$5.39
Large Strawberry Watermelon Kiwi Lemonade Refresher$5.19
Large Strawberry Watermelon Kiwi Refresher$4.89
Large Sweetened Brewed Iced Tea$3.29
Large Tropical Mango Coconut Refresher$5.39
Large Tropical Mango Lemonade Refresher$5.19
Large Tropical Mango Refresher$4.89
Large Unsweetened Brewed Iced Tea$3.29
Large Vanilla Chai Latte$5.49
Lemon Poppyseed Muffin$2.49
Medium Caramel Iced Capp$5.29
Medium Chai Latte$4.59
Medium Chai Protein Latte$5.69
Medium Coffee Mocha$3.19
Medium Cookie Butter Iced Capp$5.39
Medium Dark Roast Coffee$2.59
Medium Decaf Coffee$2.59
Medium Flavored Chai Protein Latte$5.99
Medium Flavored Matcha Protein Latte$5.99
Medium French Vanilla$3.19
Medium Half & Half Lemonade Iced Tea$2.99
Medium Hot Chocolate$3.19
Medium Iced Capp$4.39
Medium Iced Capp Light$4.59
Medium Iced Caramel Coffee$3.99
Medium Iced Chai Latte$4.49
Medium Iced Chai Protein Latte$5.49
Medium Iced Coffee Original$3.49
Medium Iced Flavored Chai Protein Latte$5.79
Medium Iced Flavored Protein Matcha Latte$5.79
Medium Iced Lemonade$3.19
Medium Iced Matcha Latte$4.69
Medium Iced Matcha Protein Latte$5.49
Medium Iced Mocha Coffee$3.99
Medium Iced Vanilla Almond Coffee$4.19
Medium Iced Vanilla Chai Latte$4.99
Medium Iced Vanilla Coffee$3.99
Medium Matcha Latte$4.39
Medium Matcha Protein Latte$5.69
Medium Mocha Iced Capp$5.19
Medium Oreo Iced Capp$5.19
Medium Original Blend Coffee$2.59
Medium Specialty Tea$2.49
Medium Steeped Tea$2.59
Medium Strawberry Lemonade$3.89
Medium Strawberry Watermelon Kiwi Coconut Refresher$4.99
Medium Strawberry Watermelon Kiwi Lemonade Refresher$4.79
Medium Strawberry Watermelon Kiwi Refresher$4.49
Medium Sweetened Brewed Iced Tea$2.89
Medium Tropical Mango Coconut Refresher$4.99
Medium Tropical Mango Lemonade Refresher$4.79
Medium Tropical Mango Refresher$4.49
Medium Unsweetened Brewed Iced Tea$2.89
Medium Vanilla Chai Latte$4.99
Milk$2.29
Muffins Dozen$22.99
Muffins Half Dozen$12.49
Old Fashioned Plain$1.79
Omelette Bites$4.19
Original Blend Coffee Take 12$22.99
Plain Bagel$2.29
Plain Croissant$2.39
Pretzel Bagel$2.29
Purple Wave TimsBoost with Red Bull$5.19
Ruby Rush TimsBoost with Red Bull$5.19
Salted Caramel Cookie made with Heath$2.19
Sausage & Bacon - Double Stacked Breakfast Wrap$5.99
Sausage & Bacon Double Stacked Farmer's Breakfast Wrap$6.89
Sausage & Bacon Egg White & Swiss Wrap$5.79
Sausage Bagel B.e.l.t$5.69
Sausage Bagel Breakfast Sandwich$5.19
Sausage Egg White & Swiss Wrap$4.89
Sausage Farmer's Breakfast Wrap$5.69
Sausage Grilled Breakfast Wrap$4.69
Sausage Maple Waffle Breakfast Sandwich$5.49
Sausage Wrap Snacker$2.79
Sausage, Egg and Cheese English Muffin$4.49
Sea Blue Red Bull Can$3.99
Small Americano$3.19
Small Cappuccino$3.59
Small Caramel Iced Capp$4.79
Small Chai Latte$4.19
Small Chai Protein Latte$5.19
Small Coffee Mocha$2.89
Small Cookie Butter Iced Capp$4.89
Small Dark Roast Coffee$2.39
Small Decaf Coffee$2.39
Small Flavored Chai Protein Latte$5.69
Small Flavored Matcha Protein Latte$5.49
Small French Vanilla$2.89
Small Half & Half Lemonade Iced Tea$2.59
Small Hot Chocolate$2.89
Small Iced Capp$3.99
Small Iced Capp Light$3.99
Small Iced Caramel Coffee$3.69
Small Iced Chai Latte$4.19
Small Iced Chai Protein Latte$5.09
Small Iced Coffee Original$3.19
Small Iced Flavored Chai Protein Latte$5.39
Small Iced Flavored Protein Matcha Latte$5.29
Small Iced Lemonade$2.89
Small Iced Matcha Latte$4.29
Small Iced Matcha Protein Latte$4.99
Small Iced Mocha Coffee$3.69
Small Iced Vanilla Almond Latte$4.39
Small Iced Vanilla Almond Milk Coffee$3.99
Small Iced Vanilla Chai Latte$4.49
Small Iced Vanilla Coffee$3.69
Small Iced Vanilla Iced Latte$4.39
Small Iced Vanilla Protein Latte$5.39
Small Matcha Latte$3.89
Small Matcha Protein Latte$5.19
Small Mocha Iced Capp$4.69
Small Oreo Iced Capp$4.69
Small Original Blend Coffee$2.39
Small Specialty Tea$2.39
Small Steeped Tea$2.39
Small Strawberry Lemonade$3.59
Small Strawberry Watermelon Kiwi Coconut Refresher$4.69
Small Strawberry Watermelon Kiwi Lemonade Refresher$4.49
Small Strawberry Watermelon Kiwi Refresher$4.19
Small Sweetened Brewed Iced Tea$2.59
Small Tropical Mango Coconut Refresher$4.69
Small Tropical Mango Lemonade Refresher$4.49
Small Tropical Mango Refresher$4.19
Small Unsweetened Brewed Iced Tea$2.49
Small Vanilla Chai Latte$4.49
Small Vanilla Protein Latte$5.49
Sour Cream Blueberry Glazed Timbit$0.60
Sour Cream Glazed$1.79
Sour Cream Glazed Timbit$0.60
Steeped Tea Take 12$21.99
Timbits 10 Pack$4.39
Timbits 20 Pack$7.89
Timbits 4 Pack$1.90
Timbits 40 Pack$11.99
Tropical Red Bull Can$4.19
Tropical Sun TimsBoost with Red Bull$5.19
Vanilla Cream$1.79
Vanilla Dip$1.79
Watermelon Red Bull Can$4.19
Wild Blueberry Muffin$2.49

Every Tim Hortons in Buffalo, NY, cheapest first

RestaurantMedium Original BlendBasketIndexPrice level (national)
2001 Main StBuffalo, NY$1.90$8.6367$$$$$
1 Scott StreetBuffalo, NY$2.59$12.6698$$$$$
380 Niagara StBuffalo, NY$2.59$12.6698$$$$$
2080 Abbott RdBuffalo, NY$2.59$12.6698$$$$$
1176 South Park AvenueBuffalo, NY$2.59$12.6698$$$$$
1777 Sheridan DrBuffalo, NY$2.59$12.6698$$$$$
875 Ellicott StBuffalo, NY$2.65$12.82100$$$$$
1405 Kensington AveBuffalo, NY$2.65$12.82100$$$$$
537 Delaware AvenueBuffalo, NY$2.64$12.91100$$$$$
474 Michigan AveBuffalo, NY$2.64$12.91100$$$$$
462 Grider STBuffalo, NY$2.64$12.91100$$$$$
2240 Delaware AveBuffalo, NY$2.64$12.91100$$$$$
1088 Niagara STBuffalo, NY$2.64$12.91100$$$$$
2200 Elmwood AveBuffalo, NY$2.64$12.91100$$$$$
424 Main STBuffalo, NY$2.64$12.91100$$$$$
3470 Main StBuffalo, NY$2.64$12.91100$$$$$
2207 Niagara StBuffalo, NY$2.64$12.91100$$$$$
2058 Delaware AveBuffalo, NY$2.64$12.91100$$$$$
1137 Bailey AveBuffalo, NY$2.74$13.12102$$$$$
647 Bailey AveBuffalo, NY$2.74$13.12102$$$$$
829 Dick RDBuffalo, NY$2.74$13.12102$$$$$
1474 Seneca StBuffalo, NY$2.74$13.12102$$$$$
2200 south park aveBuffalo, NY$2.59$13.16102$$$$$
1989 Seneca StBuffalo, NY$2.59$13.16102$$$$$
565 Abbott RdBuffalo, NY$2.90$13.90108$$$$$
2157 Main StBuffalo, NY$2.90$13.90108$$$$$

Other fast food in Buffalo, NY

More Tim Hortons prices

How these prices are measured

Every day we check the menu at every restaurant of each chain, through the same ordering app its customers use, and record each item's pickup price. Restaurants are compared on a basket of items every full-menu restaurant of that brand sells. An index of 100 is the brand's typical (median) restaurant in the country, so 95 means 5% cheaper and 110 means 10% pricier. Brands are only ever compared with themselves, never with each other.

Citing this data: Source: Drive Thru Index (https://drivethruindex.com/restaurants/us/ny/buffalo/tim-hortons-911030), prices checked 2026-11-18. You are welcome to quote any figure on this page.

Back to map