Drive Thru
Index

Tim Hortons prices in New York

266 Tim Hortons restaurants in New York, prices checked 2026-10-04.

Key findings

The scoop

The Same Basket, Twice the Price

Tim Hortons’ basket runs from $12.22 in Amherst, NY, to $24.60 in Jamaica, NY—a 101% spread across 259 stores. Its Medium Original Blend Coffee ranges from $1.90 to $3.67.

New York Ranks Sixth Cheapest

New York is 6 of 10 states for Tim Hortons basket prices, where 1 = cheapest. The state’s median basket is $17.05, 2% below the national typical price.

Turnpike Stop Joins Pricey Company

A turnpike site in Franklin Square, NY, has a $19.45 basket. That places it among the state’s priciest Tim Hortons sites, alongside Jamaica, NY, at $24.60.

Jamestown Leads Local Bargains

Jamestown, NY, has the lowest town median basket at $16.55. Rochester, NY, follows at $16.65, while Cheektowaga, NY, comes in at $16.79.

Every Tim Hortons in New York, by town

Each restaurant links to its full menu with prices. A town with its own page links to it, where every brand there is compared.

CityRestaurantsTypical Medium Original BlendRestaurant
Akron1$2.5912950 Main Rd
Akwesasne, Ny1$2.95148 State Route 37
Albion1$2.69161 S Main St
Alden1$2.5912886 Broadway St
Amherst8$2.59University AT Buffalo (north C · all 8 in Amherst
Amityville1$2.99616 Broadway
Angola1$2.628645 Erie Rd
Arcade1$2.59658 W Main ST
Batavia3$2.658400 Lewiston Rd · all 3 in Batavia
Bay Shore1$2.99236 - Bay Shore Rd
Bethpage1$2.99100 Hicksville Rd
Blasdell2$2.603638 S Park Ave · 4408 Milestrip Rd
Brentwood1$2.99400 - Suffolk Ave
Brockport1$2.896573 4th Section Rd
Brooklyn1$3.192402 Knapp St
Buffalo27$2.642001 Main St · all 27 in Buffalo
Canandaigua2$2.6910 Booth St · all 2 in Canandaigua
Canton1$2.695994 - US Highway 11
Cassadaga1$2.398008 Rt. 60
Chaffee1$2.5912479 Olean Rd
Cheektowaga10$2.583465 Union Rd · all 10 in Cheektowaga
Clarence1$2.599220 Main St
Commack1$2.992084 Jericho turnpike
Deer Park1$2.992111 - Deer Park Ave
Depew4$2.591199 French Rd · all 4 in Depew
Derby1$2.596933 Erie Rd
Dunkirk2$2.3992 Lake Shore Dr E · all 2 in Dunkirk
East Amherst2$2.599590 Transit Rd · 5989 Transit Rd
East Aurora1$2.5944 Hamburg St
East Meadow1$2.992475 Hempstead Turnpike
East Norwich1$2.996261 - Northern Blvd
East Rochester2$2.69447 W Commercial St · all 2 in East Rochester
Eden1$2.628259 N Main St
Eldersburg1$3.1911 Morningstar Rd
Ellicottville1$2.596599 Route 219 N
Elma3$2.592137 Transit Rd · 661 Jamison Rd · 950 Maple Rd
Elmont1$3.192115 Linden Blvd
Evans Mills1$2.2925744 US Route 11
Franklin Square1$2.991111 Hempstead Turnpike
Fredonia1$2.3910371 Bennett Rd
Fresh Meadows1$3.1917312 Horace Harding Expressway
Gates3$2.691563 Spencerport Rd · 2311 Chili Ave · 1508 Buffalo Rd
Geneseo1$2.691 Ryan Dr
Geneva1$2.69451 Hamilton St
Getzville2$2.591555 N French Rd · 2290 Millersport Hwy
Gowanda1$2.5965 Buffalo St
Grand Island2$2.651685 Grand Island Blvd · all 2 in Grand Island
Greece3$2.69649 Long Pond RD · all 3 in Greece
Hamburg7$2.595600 Mckinley Pkwy · all 7 in Hamburg
Hauppauge1$2.99700 - Motor Pkwy
Hempstead3$2.99797 - Peninsula Blvd · all 3 in Hempstead
Henrietta1$2.694760 W Henrietta Rd
Hicksville1$2.99285 N Broadway
Hogansburg1$2.95425 State Route 37
Holtsville1$2.991194 Portion Rd
Hornell1$2.49111 Seneca Street
Irving1$2.62675 Main Road
Islip1$2.992300 - Sunrise Hwy
Islip Terrace1$2.993309 Sunrise Hwy
Jamaica3$3.66187-05 - Hillside Ave · all 3 in Jamaica
Jamestown5$2.4910 - S Main St · all 5 in Jamestown
Kenmore2$2.741025 Kenmore Ave · all 2 in Kenmore
Lackawanna2$2.622530 Hamburg Tpke Apt Rt5 · 1340 Ridge Rd
Lakeview1$2.486550 Southwestern Blvd
Lakewood1$2.49277 E Fairmount Ave
Lancaster5$2.594220-4222 Walden Ave · all 5 in Lancaster
Levittown1$2.993730 - Hempstead Tpke
Lewiston1$2.65790 Center Street
Lockport6$2.596393 Robinson Rd · all 6 in Lockport
Malone1$2.693385 - Us-11
Massena1$2.95232 Main St
Mayville1$2.397 W Chautauqua St
Medford2$2.992664 - Rt-112 · all 2 in Medford
Medina1$2.6911305 Maple Ridge Rd
Melville1$2.99629 Broadhollow Rd
Merrick1$2.991589 - Merrick Rd
Mineola1$2.99449 Jericho Turnpike
Morristown1$2.693681 HWY 37
Newark1$2.69821 W Union St
Newfane1$2.592897 Lockport Olcott Rd
Niagara Falls9$2.656415 Niagara Falls Blvd · all 9 in Niagara Falls
North Babylon1$2.99170 - Bay Shore Rd
North Chili1$2.594380 Buffalo Rd
North Tonawanda3$2.64748 Niagara Falls Blvd · all 3 in North Tonawanda
Ogdensburg1$2.691111 Champlain St
Old Westbury1$2.993 - Jericho Tpke
Olean3$2.49501 N Union St · all 3 in Olean
Orchard Park7$2.684298 S Buffalo St · all 7 in Orchard Park
Ozone Park1$3.19100-3 North Conduit Blvd
Patchogue2$2.99770 - Montauk Hwy · all 2 in Patchogue
Pembroke1$2.651106 Main Street
Penfield1$2.692230 Penfield Rd
Piffard1$2.653667 – Main St
Pittsford1$2.69720 Pittsford Victor Rd
Plainview1$2.991099 Old Country Rd
Potsdam1$2.69154 Elm St
Raymondville1$2.699005 SH 56
Rochester11$2.691525 Lake Ave · all 11 in Rochester
Ronkonkoma3$2.99913 Portion Road · all 3 in Ronkonkoma
Roslyn Heights1$2.99225 Willis Avenue
Salamanca1$2.59567 Broad St
Sanborn1$2.652970 Saunders Settlement Rd
Seaford1$2.994030 Merrick Road
Smithtown1$2.99819 W Jericho Turnpike
South Wales1$2.557286 Olean Rd
Spencerport1$2.89403 S Union St
Springville1$2.59371 S Cascade Dr
Staten Island4$3.041700 Richmond Ave · all 4 in Staten Island
Stony Point1$3.09180 - S Liberty Dr
Syracuse3$2.893439 Erie Blvd. E · all 3 in Syracuse
Tonawanda11$2.59618 Delaware Street · all 11 in Tonawanda
Wantagh1$2.99892 - Wantagh Ave
Warsaw1$2.59461 N Main St
Watertown2$2.2921306 New York RT 12f · all 2 in Watertown
Webster2$2.691786 Empire Blvd · all 2 in Webster
West Seneca7$2.742220 Southwestern Blvd · all 7 in West Seneca
Westfield1$2.395 - Holt St
White Plains1$3.4516 Ferris Ave
Williamsville8$2.651540 Maple Rd · all 8 in Williamsville

More prices

Questions people ask

How much is a Tim Hortons Medium Original Blend in New York?
As of 2026-10-04, a Medium Original Blend costs $1.90 to $3.67 at 266 Tim Hortons restaurants in New York, typically $2.65.
Where is the cheapest Tim Hortons in New York?
The cheapest Tim Hortons in New York is at UNIVERISTY AT BUFFALO (NORTH C, Amherst, comparing the same basket at 259 restaurants (Drive Thru Index, 2026-10-04).

How these prices are measured

Every day we check the menu at every restaurant of each chain, through the same ordering app its customers use, and record each item's pickup price. Restaurants are compared on a basket of items every full-menu restaurant of that brand sells. An index of 100 is the brand's typical (median) restaurant in the country, so 95 means 5% cheaper and 110 means 10% pricier. Brands are only ever compared with themselves, never with each other.

Citing this data: Source: Drive Thru Index (https://drivethruindex.com/brands/tim-hortons/new-york), prices checked 2026-10-04. You are welcome to quote any figure on this page.

Back to map