Drive Thru
Index

Potbelly Chicken Pot Pie Cup price

A Potbelly Chicken Pot Pie Cup costs $4.99 to $6.59 across 479 US Potbelly restaurants, typically $5.29.

Pickup prices at every Potbelly as of .

Key findings

Chicken Pot Pie Cup price by state, cheapest first

RankStateTypicalRangeIndexRestaurants
1Oklahoma$4.99$4.99 to $5.39943
2Texas$5.19$4.99 to $5.499873
3Michigan$5.19$4.99 to $5.399830
4Ohio$5.19$4.99 to $5.459823
5Indiana$5.19$5.19 to $5.299815
6Kansas$5.19$5.19 to $5.19982
7Illinois$5.29$5.19 to $5.79100115
8Virginia$5.29$5.29 to $5.8910029
9Maryland$5.29$4.99 to $5.3910026
10Minnesota$5.29$5.19 to $5.3910020
11Wisconsin$5.29$5.19 to $5.3910015
12Arizona$5.29$5.29 to $5.4910011
13Mississippi$5.29$5.29 to $5.291002
14Iowa$5.29$5.29 to $5.291002
15South Dakota$5.29$5.29 to $5.291001
16Nebraska$5.29$5.29 to $5.291001
17Florida$5.39$5.39 to $5.4910220
18Washington DC$5.39$5.39 to $5.5910217
19North Carolina$5.39$5.39 to $6.5910214
20Colorado$5.39$5.39 to $5.491029
21Arkansas$5.39$5.39 to $5.391025
22Missouri$5.39$5.39 to $5.391024
23Kentucky$5.39$5.19 to $5.491024
24Utah$5.39$5.39 to $5.391023
25Alaska$5.39$5.39 to $5.591022
26North Dakota$5.39$5.39 to $5.391021
27Georgia$5.39$5.39 to $5.391021
28Tennessee$5.39$5.39 to $5.391021
29South Carolina$5.39$5.39 to $5.391021
30Massachusetts$5.49$5.49 to $6.291045
31New York$5.59$5.59 to $6.3110610
32Oregon$5.59$5.59 to $5.591065
33Washington$6.19$6.19 to $6.191179

Cheapest cities for a Chicken Pot Pie Cup

CityTypicalRangeRestaurants
Houston, TX$4.99$4.99 to $5.199
San Antonio, TX$4.99$4.99 to $4.995
Ft Worth, TX$4.99$4.99 to $5.194
Dallas, TX$5.19$5.19 to $5.198
Cincinnati, OH$5.19$5.19 to $5.195
Austin, TX$5.19$5.19 to $5.294
Ann Arbor, MI$5.19$5.19 to $5.193
Plano, TX$5.19$5.19 to $5.193
Indianapolis, IN$5.19$5.19 to $5.193
Cleveland, OH$5.19$4.99 to $5.453

Priciest cities for a Chicken Pot Pie Cup

CityTypicalRangeRestaurants
Charlotte, NC$6.59$6.59 to $6.594
Seattle, WA$6.19$6.19 to $6.193
Dulles, VA$5.89$5.29 to $5.893
Portland, OR$5.59$5.59 to $5.593
New York, NY$5.59$5.59 to $5.599
Louisville, KY$5.49$5.39 to $5.493
Boston, MA$5.49$5.49 to $6.294
Arlington, VA$5.39$5.29 to $5.393
Minneapolis, MN$5.39$5.39 to $5.393
Tampa, FL$5.39$5.39 to $5.393

Cheapest Potbelly restaurants for a Chicken Pot Pie Cup

RestaurantWherePrice
199 E Montgomery Avenue Ste KRockville, MD$4.99
3058 S University DriveFt Worth, TX$4.99
4825 Overton Ridge BoulevardFt Worth, TX$4.99
1200 McKinney StreetHouston, TX$4.99
409b University DriveCollege Station, TX$4.99

Priciest Potbelly restaurants for a Chicken Pot Pie Cup

RestaurantWherePrice
320 S Tryon StreetCharlotte, NC$6.59
4620 Piedmont Row Drive Suite 140Charlotte, NC$6.59
11611 North Community House Road Suite ACharlotte, NC$6.59
1055 Metropolitan Ave #140Charlotte, NC$6.59
Lga Airport - Terminal CFlushing, NY$6.31

More Potbelly menu prices

Questions people ask

How much is a Potbelly Chicken Pot Pie Cup?
As of 2026-11-19: A Potbelly Chicken Pot Pie Cup costs $4.99 to $6.59 across 479 US Potbelly restaurants, typically $5.29.
Which state has the cheapest Potbelly Chicken Pot Pie Cup?
Texas is the cheapest state for a Potbelly Chicken Pot Pie Cup (typically $5.19) and New York the most expensive ($5.59). Drive Thru Index, 2026-11-19.
Where is the cheapest Potbelly Chicken Pot Pie Cup?
The cheapest Potbelly Chicken Pot Pie Cup in the US is $4.99 at 199 E Montgomery Avenue Ste K, Rockville, MD. (Drive Thru Index, 2026-11-19).

How these prices are measured

Every day we check the menu at every restaurant of each chain, through the same ordering app its customers use, and record each item's pickup price. Restaurants are compared on a basket of items every full-menu restaurant of that brand sells. An index of 100 is the brand's typical (median) restaurant in the country, so 95 means 5% cheaper and 110 means 10% pricier. Brands are only ever compared with themselves, never with each other.

Citing this data: Source: Drive Thru Index (https://drivethruindex.com/items/potbelly/chicken-pot-pie-cup), prices checked 2026-11-19. You are welcome to quote any figure on this page.

Back to map