Drive Thru
Index

Arby's Small Shirley ‘n Cream price

A Arby's Small Shirley ‘n Cream costs $2.69 to $5.29 across 3,032 US Arby's restaurants, typically $3.59.

Pickup prices at every Arby's as of .

Key findings

Small Shirley ‘n Cream price by state, cheapest first

RankStateTypicalRangeIndexRestaurants
1Maine$2.99$2.99 to $3.49834
2Texas$3.09$3.09 to $4.5986124
3Mississippi$3.09$3.09 to $3.898623
4Delaware$3.45$3.45 to $3.499614
5Georgia$3.49$2.99 to $3.8997131
6Pennsylvania$3.49$3.45 to $4.7497131
7Tennessee$3.49$2.99 to $3.9997114
8Kentucky$3.49$2.99 to $3.7997106
9Illinois$3.49$3.09 to $4.4997100
10Alabama$3.49$2.99 to $3.899789
11Wisconsin$3.49$3.49 to $3.899789
12South Carolina$3.49$3.49 to $3.899783
13Utah$3.49$3.39 to $4.299759
14Iowa$3.49$3.09 to $3.899752
15Nebraska$3.49$2.69 to $3.799744
16Maryland$3.49$3.49 to $3.899741
17South Dakota$3.49$3.49 to $3.499718
18Wyoming$3.49$3.49 to $3.799716
19Louisiana$3.49$3.09 to $3.799715
20Ohio$3.59$2.99 to $4.29100260
21Michigan$3.59$3.49 to $4.29100175
22Indiana$3.59$2.99 to $3.79100164
23North Carolina$3.59$2.99 to $3.79100128
24Oklahoma$3.59$3.19 to $3.7910089
25Missouri$3.59$3.09 to $3.9910082
26Minnesota$3.59$3.39 to $3.7910071
27Kansas$3.59$3.29 to $3.7910056
28Arkansas$3.59$3.29 to $3.7910047
29Virginia$3.69$3.45 to $4.1910398
30Arizona$3.69$3.49 to $4.0910354
31Idaho$3.69$3.49 to $4.4910323
32New Jersey$3.69$3.45 to $4.691038
33Connecticut$3.69$3.69 to $3.791034
34New Hampshire$3.69$3.69 to $3.691031
35Florida$3.79$3.49 to $3.89106131
36Colorado$3.79$3.29 to $3.8910664
37West Virginia$3.79$3.49 to $3.9910644
38Nevada$3.79$3.49 to $3.8910620
39Montana$3.79$3.49 to $3.7910612
40North Dakota$3.79$3.79 to $3.7910611
41Alaska$3.89$3.89 to $3.891089
42Oregon$3.99$3.59 to $4.2911129
43Massachusetts$3.99$3.99 to $3.991112
44New York$4.09$3.29 to $4.6911460
45Washington$4.59$3.49 to $4.9912853
46New Mexico$4.59$3.49 to $4.5912823
47California$4.99$3.49 to $5.2913959
48Hawaii$5.29$5.29 to $5.291472

Cheapest cities for a Small Shirley ‘n Cream

CityTypicalRangeRestaurants
Grand Island, NE$2.69$2.69 to $2.693
Cincinnati, OH$2.99$2.99 to $3.499
Chattanooga, TN$2.99$2.99 to $2.995
Fairfield, OH$2.99$2.99 to $2.993
West Chester, OH$2.99$2.99 to $2.993
Springfield, IL$3.09$3.09 to $3.594
Dallas, TX$3.09$3.09 to $3.094
Fort Worth, TX$3.09$3.09 to $3.094
Arlington, TX$3.09$3.09 to $3.093
Houston, TX$3.09$3.09 to $3.093

Priciest cities for a Small Shirley ‘n Cream

CityTypicalRangeRestaurants
Sacramento, CA$4.99$3.99 to $4.993
Las Cruces, NM$4.59$3.49 to $4.593
Sterling Heights, MI$4.29$3.59 to $4.293
Rochester, NY$4.09$4.09 to $4.293
Syracuse, NY$4.09$4.09 to $4.093
Anchorage, AK$3.89$3.89 to $3.893
Topeka, KS$3.79$3.49 to $3.793
Centerville, OH$3.79$3.79 to $3.793
Winchester, VA$3.79$3.79 to $3.793
Elkhart, IN$3.79$3.59 to $3.793

Cheapest Arby's restaurants for a Small Shirley ‘n Cream

RestaurantWherePrice
1204 S Locust STGrand Island, NE$2.69
6975 Bosselman Avenue, Lot 8Grand Island, NE$2.69
2333 N Webb RDGrand Island, NE$2.69
1220 Perimeter Drive SECleveland, TN$2.99
720 Dinah Shore BlvdWinchester, TN$2.99

Priciest Arby's restaurants for a Small Shirley ‘n Cream

RestaurantWherePrice
98-1005 Moanalua RD Spc 238 Pearlridge CenterAiea, HI$5.29
601 S Bernardo AveSunnyvale, CA$5.29
94-866 Moloalo STWaipahu, HI$5.29
7110 Clairemont Mesa Blvd.San Diego, CA$4.99
23862 Bridger RDLake Forest, CA$4.99

More Arby's menu prices

Questions people ask

How much is a Arby's Small Shirley ‘n Cream?
As of 2026-11-22: A Arby's Small Shirley ‘n Cream costs $2.69 to $5.29 across 3,032 US Arby's restaurants, typically $3.59.
Which state has the cheapest Arby's Small Shirley ‘n Cream?
Texas is the cheapest state for a Arby's Small Shirley ‘n Cream (typically $3.09) and California the most expensive ($4.99). Drive Thru Index, 2026-11-22.
Where is the cheapest Arby's Small Shirley ‘n Cream?
The cheapest Arby's Small Shirley ‘n Cream in the US is $2.69 at 1204 S Locust ST, Grand Island, NE. (Drive Thru Index, 2026-11-22).

How these prices are measured

Every day we check the menu at every restaurant of each chain, through the same ordering app its customers use, and record each item's pickup price. Restaurants are compared on a basket of items every full-menu restaurant of that brand sells. An index of 100 is the brand's typical (median) restaurant in the country, so 95 means 5% cheaper and 110 means 10% pricier. Brands are only ever compared with themselves, never with each other.

Citing this data: Source: Drive Thru Index (https://drivethruindex.com/items/arbys/small-shirley-n-cream), prices checked 2026-11-22. You are welcome to quote any figure on this page.

Back to map