Drive Thru
Index

Arby's Medium Shirley ‘n Cream price

A Arby's Medium Shirley ‘n Cream costs $2.99 to $6.29 across 3,032 US Arby's restaurants, typically $3.99.

Pickup prices at every Arby's as of .

Key findings

Medium Shirley ‘n Cream price by state, cheapest first

RankStateTypicalRangeIndexRestaurants
1Texas$3.59$3.59 to $4.7990124
2Mississippi$3.59$3.59 to $4.399023
3Maine$3.69$3.69 to $3.99924
4Oklahoma$3.89$3.69 to $3.999789
5Delaware$3.95$3.95 to $3.999914
6Georgia$3.99$3.49 to $4.39100131
7Pennsylvania$3.99$3.95 to $5.24100131
8Tennessee$3.99$3.49 to $4.59100114
9Kentucky$3.99$3.49 to $4.29100106
10Illinois$3.99$3.59 to $4.99100100
11Alabama$3.99$3.49 to $4.3910089
12Wisconsin$3.99$3.99 to $4.3910089
13South Carolina$3.99$3.99 to $4.3910083
14Missouri$3.99$3.59 to $4.4910082
15Colorado$3.99$3.79 to $4.7910064
16Kansas$3.99$3.79 to $3.9910056
17Iowa$3.99$3.59 to $4.3910052
18Arkansas$3.99$3.59 to $3.9910047
19Nebraska$3.99$2.99 to $4.2910044
20Maryland$3.99$3.99 to $4.3910041
21Idaho$3.99$3.89 to $4.9910023
22South Dakota$3.99$3.99 to $3.9910018
23Wyoming$3.99$3.79 to $4.5910016
24Louisiana$3.99$3.59 to $4.2910015
25New Hampshire$3.99$3.99 to $3.991001
26Ohio$4.09$3.49 to $4.59103260
27Michigan$4.09$3.99 to $4.89103175
28Indiana$4.09$3.49 to $4.29103164
29North Carolina$4.09$3.49 to $4.29103128
30Minnesota$4.09$3.89 to $4.2910371
31Utah$4.09$3.89 to $4.7910359
32Virginia$4.19$3.69 to $4.6910598
33Arizona$4.19$3.99 to $4.7910554
34New Jersey$4.19$3.95 to $4.991058
35Connecticut$4.19$4.19 to $4.291054
36Massachusetts$4.19$4.19 to $4.191052
37Florida$4.29$3.99 to $4.39108131
38West Virginia$4.29$3.99 to $4.3910844
39Nevada$4.29$3.99 to $4.3910820
40Montana$4.29$3.99 to $4.2910812
41North Dakota$4.29$4.29 to $4.2910811
42Alaska$4.39$4.39 to $4.391109
43New York$4.49$3.59 to $4.9911360
44Oregon$4.49$3.89 to $5.2511329
45Washington$4.79$4.19 to $5.2912053
46New Mexico$4.79$3.99 to $4.7912023
47California$5.29$3.79 to $6.2913359
48Hawaii$5.99$5.99 to $5.991502

Cheapest cities for a Medium Shirley ‘n Cream

CityTypicalRangeRestaurants
Grand Island, NE$2.99$2.99 to $2.993
Cincinnati, OH$3.49$3.49 to $3.999
Chattanooga, TN$3.49$3.49 to $3.495
West Chester, OH$3.49$3.49 to $3.493
Fairfield, OH$3.49$3.49 to $3.493
Fort Worth, TX$3.59$3.59 to $3.594
Springfield, IL$3.59$3.59 to $4.094
Dallas, TX$3.59$3.59 to $3.594
Bloomington, IN$3.59$3.59 to $3.593
Terre Haute, IN$3.59$3.59 to $3.593

Priciest cities for a Medium Shirley ‘n Cream

CityTypicalRangeRestaurants
Sacramento, CA$5.29$4.49 to $5.293
Sterling Heights, MI$4.89$4.09 to $4.893
Las Cruces, NM$4.79$3.99 to $4.793
Rochester, NY$4.69$4.49 to $4.693
Syracuse, NY$4.69$4.69 to $4.693
Anchorage, AK$4.39$4.39 to $4.393
Centerville, OH$4.29$4.29 to $4.293
Huntington, WV$4.29$4.29 to $4.293
Myrtle Beach, SC$4.29$3.99 to $4.293
Ocala, FL$4.29$3.99 to $4.393

Cheapest Arby's restaurants for a Medium Shirley ‘n Cream

RestaurantWherePrice
1204 S Locust STGrand Island, NE$2.99
6975 Bosselman Avenue, Lot 8Grand Island, NE$2.99
2333 N Webb RDGrand Island, NE$2.99
1220 Perimeter Drive SECleveland, TN$3.49
720 Dinah Shore BlvdWinchester, TN$3.49

Priciest Arby's restaurants for a Medium Shirley ‘n Cream

RestaurantWherePrice
601 S Bernardo AveSunnyvale, CA$6.29
98-1005 Moanalua RD Spc 238 Pearlridge CenterAiea, HI$5.99
913 W Manchester BlvdInglewood, CA$5.99
6850 Reseda BlvdReseda, CA$5.99
745 W Clover RDTracy, CA$5.99

More Arby's menu prices

Questions people ask

How much is a Arby's Medium Shirley ‘n Cream?
As of 2026-11-22: A Arby's Medium Shirley ‘n Cream costs $2.99 to $6.29 across 3,032 US Arby's restaurants, typically $3.99.
Which state has the cheapest Arby's Medium Shirley ‘n Cream?
Texas is the cheapest state for a Arby's Medium Shirley ‘n Cream (typically $3.59) and California the most expensive ($5.29). Drive Thru Index, 2026-11-22.
Where is the cheapest Arby's Medium Shirley ‘n Cream?
The cheapest Arby's Medium Shirley ‘n Cream in the US is $2.99 at 1204 S Locust ST, Grand Island, NE. (Drive Thru Index, 2026-11-22).

How these prices are measured

Every day we check the menu at every restaurant of each chain, through the same ordering app its customers use, and record each item's pickup price. Restaurants are compared on a basket of items every full-menu restaurant of that brand sells. An index of 100 is the brand's typical (median) restaurant in the country, so 95 means 5% cheaper and 110 means 10% pricier. Brands are only ever compared with themselves, never with each other.

Citing this data: Source: Drive Thru Index (https://drivethruindex.com/items/arbys/medium-shirley-n-cream), prices checked 2026-11-22. You are welcome to quote any figure on this page.

Back to map