How much is a Five Guys Hamburger in New York?

As of 2026-10-03, a Hamburger costs $9.99 to $12.45 at 87 Five Guys restaurants in New York, typically $10.89.

Where is the cheapest Five Guys in New York?

The cheapest Five Guys in New York is at 210-33 26th Avenue, Bayside, comparing the same basket at 79 restaurants (Drive Thru Index, 2026-10-03).

Five Guys prices in New York

Name: Five Guys Prices in New York (2026) | Drive Thru Index
Creator: Drive Thru Index
License: https://drivethruindex.com/insights#citing

87 Five Guys restaurants in New York, prices checked 2026-10-03.

Key findings

A Five Guys Hamburger typically costs $10.89 in New York ($9.99 to $12.45 across 87 restaurants). Five Guys here is level with its typical price in the US.

The scoop

Manhattan Sits At The Top
Five Guys' priciest basket in this view is in New York, NY at $32.14. Its Hamburger is $12.45 there, the top end of the $9.99 to $12.45 range.

Queens Brings The Bargain Basket
The lowest Five Guys basket in the state is in Queens, NY at $26.26. The Hamburger there is $9.99.

A 22% Five Guys Spread
Across 78 Five Guys restaurants in NY, the basket stretches 22% from low to high. That is a chunky swing for the same Hamburger, Hot Dog, Regular Fries and Regular Drink basket.

NY Matches The National Typical
The median Five Guys basket in NY is $28.52. That sits at 0% versus the national typical price, with the state ranked 29 of 46 states where 1 = cheapest.

Every Five Guys in New York, by town

Each restaurant links to its full menu with prices. A town with its own page links to it, where every brand there is compared.

City	Restaurants	Typical Hamburger	Restaurant
Albany	3	$10.89	900 Central Ave · all 3 in Albany
Amherst	2	$10.89	1551 Niagara Falls Blvd Suite 2 · all 2 in Amherst
Amityville	1	$10.45	45-a Merrick Road
Amsterdam	1	$10.89	4855 State Highway 30
Batavia	1	$10.89	4234 Veterans Memorial Drive
Bay Shore	1	$10.45	1701 Sunrise Highway, Suite A18
Bayside	1	$9.99	210-33 26th Avenue
Bronx	1	$10.75	815 Hutchinson River Pkwy.
Brooklyn	5	$10.75	2159 Ralph Ave. · all 5 in Brooklyn
Buffalo	1	$10.89	2636 Delaware Ave.
Cheektowaga	2	$10.89	4900 Transit Rd. Suite 900 · all 2 in Cheektowaga
Clifton Park	1	$10.89	7 Southside Drive
Commack	1	$10.45	6546 Jericho Turnpike
Deer Park	1	$10.45	1942 Deer Park Ave
Dewitt	1	$10.89	3179 Erie Blvd.
Elmira	1	$10.89	950 County Rd, Rt. 64
Farmingdale	1	$10.45	2263 Broadhollow Road (Route 110
Fishkill	1	$10.15	10 Westage Dr
Fresh Meadows	1	$10.75	6122 188th St.
Glenmont	1	$10.89	241 Route 9 West
Glenville	1	$10.89	262 Saratoga Road
Greece	1	$10.89	1948 Ridge Rd. W.
Hamburg	1	$10.89	3860 McKinley Parkway
Hauppauge	1	$10.45	601 Veteran's Highway
Henrietta	1	$10.89	1100 Jefferson Road
Ithaca	1	$10.89	222 Elmira Rd
Johnson City	1	$10.89	601 Harry L Drive Oakdale Commons, Suite 13
Kingston	1	$10.15	1202 Ulster Ave
Latham	1	$10.89	602 New Loudon Road
Liverpool	1	$10.89	3810 Nys Route 31
Lockport	1	$10.89	5716 S Transit Rd. Suite 50
Malta	1	$10.89	4 Kelch Drive
Middletown	1	$10.15	469 Route 211 East
Mohegan Lake	1	$10.15	3121 E. Main St.
Mount Kisco	1	$10.15	360 North Bedford Rd.
Nanuet	1	$10.15	43 East Route 59 Rockland Center
New Hartford	1	$10.79	4829 Commercial Dr.
New York	11	$11.85	36 West 48th Street · all 11 in New York
Newburgh	1	$10.15	1278 Suite C Rt 300
Niagara Falls	1	$10.89	1785 Military Road
Ny	1	$11.85	80 Maiden Lane
Oneonta	1	$10.89	5006 State Highway 23, Ste. 31
Pelham Manor	1	$10.75	798 Pelham Parkway
Penfield	1	$10.89	2067 Fairport Nine Mile Point Road
Plattsburgh	1	$10.89	418 State Route 3
Port Jefferson Station	1	$10.45	5122 Nesconset Hwy
Potsdam	1	$10.89	79 Market Street
Poughkeepsie	1	$10.15	2507 South Road, #104
Queens	2	$10.37	254-55 Horace Harding Expressway · all 2 in Queens
Queensbury	1	$10.89	735 Upper Glen Street
Rensselaer	1	$10.89	600 North Greenbush Road
Rochester	1	$10.89	1881 Monroe Ave Rochester New York
Saratoga Springs	1	$10.89	3057 Rt.50
Schenectady	1	$10.89	418 Balltown Road
Selden	1	$10.45	202 Independence Plaza
Shirley	1	$10.45	855 Montauk Highway
Staten Island	1	$10.75	2865 Richmond Ave.
Syracuse	2	$10.89	727 S. Crouse Ave. · all 2 in Syracuse
Utica	1	$10.89	756 Horatio St., Suite D
Vestal	1	$10.89	4700 Vestal Parkway East
Victor	1	$10.89	405 Commerce Drive
Watertown	1	$10.89	1290 Arsenal Street
Webster	1	$10.89	927 Holt Rd Suite 200 New York
White Plains	1	$10.75	240 Main Street
Woodside	1	$9.99	5124 Northern Blvd
Yonkers	2	$10.75	5540 Xavier DR · all 2 in Yonkers

More prices

Questions people ask

How much is a Five Guys Hamburger in New York?: As of 2026-10-03, a Hamburger costs $9.99 to $12.45 at 87 Five Guys restaurants in New York, typically $10.89.
Where is the cheapest Five Guys in New York?: The cheapest Five Guys in New York is at 210-33 26th Avenue, Bayside, comparing the same basket at 79 restaurants (Drive Thru Index, 2026-10-03).

How these prices are measured

Every day we check the menu at every restaurant of each chain, through the same ordering app its customers use, and record each item's pickup price. Restaurants are compared on a basket of items every full-menu restaurant of that brand sells. An index of 100 is the brand's typical (median) restaurant in the country, so 95 means 5% cheaper and 110 means 10% pricier. Brands are only ever compared with themselves, never with each other.

Citing this data: Source: Drive Thru Index (https://drivethruindex.com/brands/five-guys/new-york), prices checked 2026-10-03. You are welcome to quote any figure on this page.