Drive Thru
Index

Cold Stone Creamery prices in New York

45 Cold Stone Creamery restaurants in New York, prices checked 2026-11-19.

Key findings

The scoop

A $16.90 Cold Stone swing

Cold Stone Creamery’s basket runs from $28.06 in Vestal, NY, to $44.96 in Pleasantville, NY. That is a 60% spread across 45 stores, while Create Your Own (Like It) ranges from $5.59 to $8.99.

New York ranks 41st for value

New York’s Cold Stone Creamery basket ranks 41 of 43 states, with 1 being cheapest. Its $36.00 median basket is 11% above the national typical price.

Vestal serves the state’s bargain basket

Vestal, NY, has the lowest Cold Stone Creamery basket in view at $28.06. Pleasantville, NY, takes the top end at $44.96.

Every Cold Stone Creamery in New York, by town

Each restaurant links to its full menu with prices. A town with its own page links to it, where every brand there is compared.

CityRestaurantsTypical Create Your Own (Like It)Restaurant
Albany1$7.491475 Western Avenue
Astoria1$8.2925-98 Steinway Street
Babylon1$7.49255 Deer Park Avenue
Bayside1$7.99212-65 26th Ave
Bronx2$7.212069 Bartow Ave · all 2 in Bronx
Brooklyn5$7.59815 Flatbush avenue · all 5 in Brooklyn
Carle Place1$7.99196 Glen Cove Rd, Unit 14
Centereach1$7.992350-c Middle Country Road
Clifton Park1$7.99309 Clifton Park Ctr RD Ste 4
Commack1$7.496401 Jericho Turnpike Suite 103
Elmhurst1$7.9988-01 Queens Blvd
Elmont1$7.50600 Hempstead Tpke
Fishkill1$7.4911 Merrit Blvd, US Route 9
Garden City1$7.99984 Franklin Avenue
Glendale1$7.758028 Cooper Avenue
Great Neck1$7.49509 Great Neck Rd
Howard Beach1$7.21157-14 Crossbay Blvd
Ithaca1$5.59222 Elmira Rd Suite 6
Jericho1$7.49297 North Broadway
Levittown1$7.503535 Hempstead Turnpike
Long Beach1$6.9985 East Park Avenue
Lynbrook1$7.506 Broadway
Massapequa1$7.5025 Hickville Rd
Merrick1$7.502154 Merrick Rd
New York1$8.99350 West 42nd Street
Orchard Park1$5.993464 Amelia Drive
Patchogue1$7.99499-57 Sunrise Highway
Pleasantville1$8.9964 Washington Avenue
Scarsdale1$8.25993 Central Park Avenue
Shirley1$7.49999 Montauk Highway, Unit 19 Unit 19
Smithtown1$7.9944 East Main Street Village Commons Shopping Center
Somers1$7.4980 Route 6 Somers Common Center
Staten Island2$7.192341 Richmond Avenue · all 2 in Staten Island
Syracuse1$6.199655 Carousel Center
Valley Stream1$7.50750 W Sunrise Highway Suite 4105 Next to Citizens Bank
Vestal1$5.594700 Vestal Parkway East
Webster1$5.991028 Ridge Road #127
White Plains1$8.4925 Mamaroneck Avenue
Woodmere1$7.50253-01 Rockaway Blvd Ste 25a

More prices

Questions people ask

How much is a Cold Stone Creamery Create Your Own (Like It) in New York?
As of 2026-11-19, a Create Your Own (Like It) costs $5.59 to $8.99 at 45 Cold Stone Creamery restaurants in New York, typically $7.50.
Where is the cheapest Cold Stone Creamery in New York?
The cheapest Cold Stone Creamery in New York is at 222 Elmira Rd Suite 6, Ithaca, comparing the same basket at 45 restaurants (Drive Thru Index, 2026-11-19).

How these prices are measured

Every day we check the menu at every restaurant of each chain, through the same ordering app its customers use, and record each item's pickup price. Restaurants are compared on a basket of items every full-menu restaurant of that brand sells. An index of 100 is the brand's typical (median) restaurant in the country, so 95 means 5% cheaper and 110 means 10% pricier. Brands are only ever compared with themselves, never with each other.

Citing this data: Source: Drive Thru Index (https://drivethruindex.com/brands/cold-stone-creamery/new-york), prices checked 2026-11-19. You are welcome to quote any figure on this page.

Back to map