Carvel menu prices, 25 N Main Street Montauk Hwy, Sayville, NY
$$$$$ About average for a Carvel in the US
#140of 272Carvel in the US
#76of 183in New York
#3of 17within 10 mi
Rank by the price of the same basket of items: #1 is the cheapest Carvel.
Cheapest Carvel within 10 mi
Every restaurant of the brand within that distance, cheapest first by the same basket of items. Distances are in a straight line.
| Rank | Restaurant | Distance | Small Sundae | Basket | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 642 middle country rdSelden, NY | 9.3 mi | $5.99 | $10.98 | −$0.90 |
| 2 | 1064 Motor PkwyCentral Islip, NY | 8.2 mi | $6.29 | $11.68 | −$0.20 |
| 3 | 25 N Main Street Montauk HwySayville, NY this restaurant | 0.0 mi | $6.39 | $11.88 | — |
| 4 | 776 Montauk HwyBayport, NY | 1.7 mi | $6.39 | $11.88 | ±$0.00 |
| 5 | 290 Ronkonkoma AveLake Ronkonkoma, NY | 5.6 mi | $6.39 | $11.88 | ±$0.00 |
| 6 | 2301 Ny-112Medford, NY | 7.0 mi | $6.43 | $11.92 | +$0.04 |
| 7 | 400 A Horseblock RDFarmingville, NY | 7.1 mi | $6.43 | $11.92 | +$0.04 |
| 8 | 2195 Middle Country RoadCentereach, NY | 8.5 mi | $6.43 | $11.92 | +$0.04 |
| 9 | 480 Patchogue Holbrook Rd Unit 13Holbrook, NY | 4.3 mi | $6.49 | $11.98 | +$0.10 |
| 10 | 77 Route 111Smithtown, NY | 9.7 mi | $6.59 | $12.08 | +$0.20 |
| 11 | 386 Portion RoadLake Ronkonkoma, NY | 6.4 mi | $6.59 | $12.28 | +$0.40 |
| 12 | 680 Middle Country Rd.Saint James, NY | 9.4 mi | $6.59 | $12.38 | +$0.50 |
| 13 | 216 East Main StEast Islip, NY | 5.1 mi | $6.69 | $12.48 | +$0.60 |
| 14 | 3311 Veterans Memorial HwyRonkonkoma, NY | 4.3 mi | $7.09 | $13.08 | +$1.20 |
| 15 | 553 Veterans Memorial HighwayHauppauge, NY | 9.0 mi | $6.99 | $13.28 | +$1.40 |
| 16 | 790 County Road, Southampton SouthamptonSouthampton, NY | 9.2 mi | $7.29 | $13.28 | +$1.40 |
| 17 | 217 East Main StreetPatchogue, NY | 4.4 mi | $7.19 | $13.38 | +$1.50 |
- A Small Sundae costs $6.39 at this Carvel (checked 2026-10-08).
- Its basket of 2 items (Small Sundae, The Original Soft Serve Small Cup) costs $11.88, level with the typical Carvel in the US.
- That is 1% below the typical Carvel in New York.
- It is the 76th cheapest of 183 Carvel restaurants in New York on that basket.
25 N Main Street Montauk Hwy, Sayville, NY 11782. See it on the map
Where this restaurant sits among every Carvel in the US
Its basket is cheaper than at 45% of the 272 Carvel restaurants in the US.
Full menu with prices (109 items)
Pickup prices from the Carvel app, checked 2026-10-08. Items linked to their own page show how that price compares across the US.
| Item | Pickup |
|---|---|
| Carvelanches | |
| Build Your Own Carvelanche Large - 24oz | $9.99 |
| Build Your Own Carvelanche Medium - 16oz | $8.59 |
| Build Your Own Carvelanche Small - 12oz | $7.59 |
| Chocolate Crunchies Carvelanche Large - 24oz | $9.99 |
| Chocolate Crunchies Carvelanche Medium - 16oz | $8.59 |
| Chocolate Crunchies Carvelanche Small - 12oz | $7.59 |
| Cookie Dough Carvelanche Large - 24oz | $9.99 |
| Cookie Dough Carvelanche Medium - 16oz | $8.59 |
| Cookie Dough Carvelanche Small - 12oz | $7.59 |
| M&M's Carvelanche Large - 24oz | $9.99 |
| M&M's Carvelanche Medium - 16oz | $8.59 |
| M&M's Carvelanche Small - 12oz | $7.59 |
| Reese's Peanut Butter Cups Carvelanche Large - 24oz | $9.99 |
| Reese's Peanut Butter Cups Carvelanche Medium - 16oz | $8.59 |
| Reese's Peanut Butter Cups Carvelanche Small - 12oz | $7.59 |
| Extras | |
| 9oz Cup of Bananas | $5.00 |
| 9oz Cup of Caramel Topping | $5.00 |
| 9oz Cup of Chocolate Crunchies | $5.00 |
| 9oz Cup of Chocolate Sprinkles | $5.00 |
| 9oz Cup of Chocolate Syrup | $5.00 |
| 9oz Cup of Confetti Sprinkles | $5.00 |
| 9oz Cup of Crushed Peanuts | $5.00 |
| 9oz Cup of Fudge | $5.00 |
| 9oz Cup of Marshmallow | $5.00 |
| 9oz Cup of Pineapple | $5.00 |
| 9oz Cup of Pound Cake | $5.00 |
| 9oz Cup of Rainbow Sprinkles | $5.00 |
| 9oz Cup of Reese's Peanut Butter Sauce | $5.00 |
| 9oz Cup of Strawberries | $5.00 |
| 9oz Cup of Wet Walnuts | $5.00 |
| Standard Candles | $3.00 |
| Ice Cream | |
| Scooped Ice Cream Pint | $8.00 |
| Scooped Ice Cream Quart | $15.00 |
| The Original Soft Serve Kids Cup | $3.59 |
| The Original Soft Serve Large Cup | $7.29 |
| The Original Soft Serve Medium Cup | $6.39 |
| The Original Soft Serve Pint | $8.00 |
| The Original Soft Serve Quart | $15.00 |
| The Original Soft Serve Small Cup | $5.49 |
| Ice Cream Sandwiches | |
| Chipsters 6 Pack | $16.00 |
| Chipsters Individual | $3.00 |
| Chocolate Crunchies Flying Saucers 6 Pack | $16.00 |
| Chocolate Crunchies Flying Saucers Individual | $3.00 |
| Flying Saucers 6 Pack | $15.00 |
| Flying Saucers Individual | $3.00 |
| Oreo Rounders | $16.00 |
| Sprinkle Flying Saucers 6 Pack | $16.00 |
| Sprinkle Flying Saucers Individual | $3.00 |
| Limited Time | |
| S'mores Scooped | $7.29 |
| Toasted Marshmallow Soft Serve | $7.29 |
| Ready Now Cakes | |
| Cookie Puss | $41.00 |
| Crunchie Munchie Monster Cake | $35.99 |
| Fudgie the Whale | $42.00 |
| Game Ball | $42.00 |
| Round Ice Cream Cake Medium (Serves 14-16) | $45.00 |
| Round Ice Cream Cake Small (Serves 10-12) | $37.00 |
| Sheet Ice Cream Cake Large (Serves 35-40) | $80.00 |
| Sheet Ice Cream Cake Medium (Serves 22-26) | $61.00 |
| Sheet Ice Cream Cake Small (Serves 14-16) | $45.00 |
| Square Ice Cream Cake Medium (Serves 6-8) | $37.00 |
| Square Ice Cream Cake Small (Serves 4-6) | $25.00 |
| Seasonal | |
| Pumpkin Cake | $37.00 |
| Shakes | |
| Black and White Shake Large Shake - 24oz | $8.99 |
| Black and White Shake Medium Shake - 16oz | $7.89 |
| Black and White Shake Small Shake - 12oz | $7.58 |
| Chocolate Shake Large Shake - 24oz | $8.99 |
| Chocolate Shake Medium Shake - 16oz | $7.89 |
| Chocolate Shake Small Shake - 12oz | $7.58 |
| Cookie Dough Shake Large Shake - 24oz | $8.99 |
| Cookie Dough Shake Medium Shake - 16oz | $7.89 |
| Cookie Dough Shake Small Shake - 12oz | $7.58 |
| Mint Chocolate Chip Shake Large Shake - 24oz | $8.99 |
| Mint Chocolate Chip Shake Medium Shake - 16oz | $7.89 |
| Mint Chocolate Chip Shake Small Shake - 12oz | $7.58 |
| Oreo Cookie Shake Large Shake - 24oz | $8.99 |
| Oreo Cookie Shake Medium Shake - 16oz | $7.89 |
| Oreo Cookie Shake Small Shake - 12oz | $7.58 |
| Pistachio Shake Large Shake - 24oz | $8.99 |
| Pistachio Shake Medium Shake - 16oz | $7.89 |
| Pistachio Shake Small Shake - 12oz | $7.58 |
| Reese's Peanut Butter Shake Large Shake - 24oz | $8.99 |
| Reese's Peanut Butter Shake Medium Shake - 16oz | $7.89 |
| Reese's Peanut Butter Shake Small Shake - 12oz | $7.58 |
| Strawberry Shake Large Shake - 24oz | $8.99 |
| Strawberry Shake Medium Shake - 16oz | $7.89 |
| Strawberry Shake Small Shake - 12oz | $7.58 |
| Vanilla Shake Large Shake - 24oz | $8.99 |
| Vanilla Shake Medium Shake - 16oz | $7.89 |
| Vanilla Shake Small Shake - 12oz | $7.58 |
| Signature Treats | |
| Bonnet Cone 4 Pack | $16.00 |
| Bonnet Cone Individual | $5.00 |
| Sprinkle Cups | $16.00 |
| Sundae Dashers | |
| Bananas Foster Sundae Dasher Medium - 16oz | $8.59 |
| Bananas Foster Sundae Dasher Small - 12oz | $7.59 |
| Carvel Crunchies Sundae Dasher Medium Dasher | $8.59 |
| Carvel Crunchies Sundae Dasher Small Dasher | $7.59 |
| Fudge Brownie Sundae Dasher Medium - 16oz | $8.59 |
| Fudge Brownie Sundae Dasher Small - 12oz | $7.59 |
| Heath Sundae Dasher Medium - 16oz | $8.59 |
| Heath Sundae Dasher Small - 12oz | $7.59 |
| Mint Chocolate Chip Sundae Dasher Medium - 16oz | $8.59 |
| Mint Chocolate Chip Sundae Dasher Small - 12oz | $7.59 |
| Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups Sundae Dasher Medium - 16oz | $8.59 |
| Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups Sundae Dasher Small - 12oz | $7.59 |
| Strawberry Shortcake Sundae Dasher Medium - 16oz | $8.59 |
| Strawberry Shortcake Sundae Dasher Small - 12oz | $7.59 |
| Sundaes | |
| Large Sundae | $8.19 |
| Medium Sundae | $7.29 |
| Small Sundae | $6.39 |
Other fast food in Sayville, NY
More Carvel prices
How these prices are measured
Every day we check the menu at every restaurant of each chain, through the same ordering app its customers use, and record each item's pickup price. Restaurants are compared on a basket of items every full-menu restaurant of that brand sells. An index of 100 is the brand's typical (median) restaurant in the country, so 95 means 5% cheaper and 110 means 10% pricier. Brands are only ever compared with themselves, never with each other.
Citing this data: Source: Drive Thru Index (https://drivethruindex.com/restaurants/us/ny/sayville/carvel-280728), prices checked 2026-10-08. You are welcome to quote any figure on this page.