Jersey Mike's menu prices, 1595 Niagara Falls Blvd, Amherst, NY
$$$$$ About average for a Jersey Mike's in the US
#1,878of 3,286Jersey Mike's in the US
#45of 122in New York
#3of 3in Amherst
#6of 7within 10 mi
Rank by the price of the same basket of items: #1 is the cheapest Jersey Mike's.
Cheapest Jersey Mike's within 10 mi
Every restaurant of the brand within that distance, cheapest first by the same basket of items. Distances are in a straight line.
| Rank | Restaurant | Distance | Original Italian | Basket | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 3030 Niagara Falls BoulevardAmherst, NY | 2.6 mi | $10.75 | $29.47 | −$0.65 |
| 2 | 3611 Delaware AvenueTonawanda, NY | 2.9 mi | $10.75 | $29.47 | −$0.65 |
| 3 | 2236 Delaware AvenueBuffalo, NY | 4.5 mi | $10.75 | $29.47 | −$0.65 |
| 4 | 5712 Main StreetWilliamsville, NY | 4.7 mi | $10.75 | $29.47 | −$0.65 |
| 5 | 8100 Transit RdAmherst, NY | 6.2 mi | $10.85 | $29.73 | −$0.39 |
| 6 | 1595 Niagara Falls BlvdAmherst, NY this restaurant | 0.0 mi | $10.95 | $30.12 | — |
| 7 | 3385 Union RoadCheektowaga, NY | 7.2 mi | $10.95 | $30.12 | ±$0.00 |
- A Original Italian costs $10.95 at this Jersey Mike's (checked 2026-10-04).
- Its basket of 6 items (Regular The Original Italian, Regular Turkey and Provolone, Regular Chips, Regular Fountain Drink, Regular Cookie, Regular Brownie) costs $30.12, 1% above the typical Jersey Mike's in the US.
- It is the 3rd cheapest of 3 Jersey Mike's restaurants in Amherst, NY on that basket.
- That is 4% below the typical Jersey Mike's in New York.
- It is the 45th cheapest of 122 Jersey Mike's restaurants in New York on that basket.
1595 Niagara Falls Blvd, Amherst, NY 14228. See it on the map
Where this restaurant sits among every Jersey Mike's in the US
Its basket is cheaper than at 43% of the 3,286 Jersey Mike's restaurants in the US.
Full menu with prices (121 items)
Pickup prices from the Jersey Mike's app, checked 2026-10-04. Items linked to their own page show how that price compares across the US.
| Item | Pickup |
|---|---|
| Dessert | |
| Mini Pack Cookie | $4.25 |
| Regular Brownie | $2.69 |
| Regular Cookie | $1.75 |
| Regular GF Snickerdoodle | $2.75 |
| Three Pack Cookie | $4.25 |
| Drinks | |
| 12 oz Can Stubborn Soda | $2.89 |
| 12 oz Celsius | $3.59 |
| 18.5 oz Pure Leaf Tea | $3.09 |
| 20 oz Bottled Water | $2.59 |
| 20 oz Gatorade | $3.09 |
| 20 oz Soda Bottle | $3.09 |
| Giant Fountain Drink | $2.99 |
| Regular Fountain Drink | $2.79 |
| Feature Sandwich | |
| Bowl Blt | $9.95 |
| Bowl Cancro Special | $11.75 |
| Bowl Stickball Special | $8.95 |
| Bowl The Number Four | $9.95 |
| Giant Blt | $17.95 |
| Giant Cancro Special | $19.95 |
| Giant Stickball Special | $17.15 |
| Giant The Number Four | $17.95 |
| Mini Blt | $7.45 |
| Mini Cancro Special | $8.45 |
| Mini Stickball Special | $7.15 |
| Mini The Number Four | $7.45 |
| Regular Blt | $9.95 |
| Regular Cancro Special | $11.75 |
| Regular Stickball Special | $8.95 |
| Regular The Number Four | $9.95 |
| Wrap Blt | $9.95 |
| Wrap Cancro Special | $11.75 |
| Wrap Stickball Special | $8.95 |
| Wrap The Number Four | $9.95 |
| Main Combo | |
| Giant Drink & Chips | $4.49 |
| Kids Meal with Water | $6.75 |
| Regular Drink & Chips | $4.29 |
| Sandwich | |
| Bowl Bacon Ranch Chicken Cheese Steak | $10.50 |
| Bowl Big Kahuna Cheese Steak | $10.90 |
| Bowl Big Kahuna Chicken Cheese Steak | $10.60 |
| Bowl Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak | $10.65 |
| Bowl California Chicken Cheese Steak | $10.45 |
| Bowl Chipotle Cheese Steak | $10.70 |
| Bowl Chipotle Chicken Cheese Steak | $10.35 |
| Bowl Club Sub | $10.95 |
| Bowl Club Supreme | $11.35 |
| Bowl Ham and Provolone | $8.95 |
| Bowl Jersey Shore's Favorite | $8.95 |
| Bowl Mike's Chicken Philly | $10.15 |
| Bowl Mike's Famous Philly | $10.50 |
| Bowl Mike's Hot Italian | $8.95 |
| Bowl Roast Beef and Provolone | $11.45 |
| Bowl The Original Italian | $10.95 |
| Bowl The Super Sub | $9.95 |
| Bowl The Veggie | $8.95 |
| Bowl Tuna Fish | $9.95 |
| Bowl Turkey and Provolone | $9.95 |
| Giant Bacon Ranch Chicken Cheese Steak | $19.25 |
| Giant Big Kahuna Cheese Steak | $19.65 |
| Giant Big Kahuna Chicken Cheese Steak | $18.95 |
| Giant Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak | $18.95 |
| Giant California Chicken Cheese Steak | $18.25 |
| Giant Chipotle Cheese Steak | $18.70 |
| Giant Chipotle Chicken Cheese Steak | $18.45 |
| Giant Club Sub | $18.95 |
| Giant Club Supreme | $19.75 |
| Giant Ham and Provolone | $16.95 |
| Giant Jersey Shore's Favorite | $16.95 |
| Giant Mike's Chicken Philly | $18.25 |
| Giant Mike's Famous Philly | $18.50 |
| Giant Mike's Hot Italian | $16.95 |
| Giant Roast Beef and Provolone | $19.90 |
| Giant The Original Italian | $18.95 |
| Giant The Super Sub | $17.95 |
| Giant The Veggie | $16.95 |
| Giant Tuna Fish | $17.95 |
| Giant Turkey and Provolone | $17.95 |
| Mini Club Sub | $8.15 |
| Mini Club Supreme | $8.35 |
| Mini Ham and Provolone | $7.25 |
| Mini Jersey Shore's Favorite | $7.25 |
| Mini Roast Beef and Provolone | $8.20 |
| Mini The Original Italian | $7.95 |
| Mini The Super Sub | $7.45 |
| Mini The Veggie | $6.95 |
| Mini Tuna Fish | $7.45 |
| Mini Turkey and Provolone | $7.45 |
| Regular Bacon Ranch Chicken Cheese Steak | $10.50 |
| Regular Big Kahuna Cheese Steak | $10.90 |
| Regular Big Kahuna Chicken Cheese Steak | $10.60 |
| Regular Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak | $10.65 |
| Regular California Chicken Cheese Steak | $10.45 |
| Regular Chipotle Cheese Steak | $10.70 |
| Regular Chipotle Chicken Cheese Steak | $10.35 |
| Regular Club Sub | $10.95 |
| Regular Club Supreme | $11.35 |
| Regular Ham and Provolone | $8.95 |
| Regular Jersey Shore's Favorite | $8.95 |
| Regular Mike's Chicken Philly | $10.15 |
| Regular Mike's Famous Philly | $10.50 |
| Regular Mike's Hot Italian | $8.95 |
| Regular Roast Beef and Provolone | $11.45 |
| Regular The Original Italian | $10.95 |
| Regular The Super Sub | $9.95 |
| Regular The Veggie | $8.95 |
| Regular Tuna Fish | $9.95 |
| Regular Turkey and Provolone | $9.95 |
| Wrap Club Sub | $10.95 |
| Wrap Club Supreme | $11.35 |
| Wrap Ham and Provolone | $8.95 |
| Wrap Jersey Shore's Favorite | $8.95 |
| Wrap Roast Beef and Provolone | $11.45 |
| Wrap The Original Italian | $10.95 |
| Wrap The Super Sub | $9.95 |
| Wrap The Veggie | $8.95 |
| Wrap Tuna Fish | $9.95 |
| Wrap Turkey and Provolone | $9.95 |
| Sides | |
| 16 oz Hot Chopped Pepper Relish | $5.95 |
| Regular Chips | $1.99 |
| Store Specials | |
| 20oz Bottled Soda & Chips | $4.59 |
| 20oz Bottled Water & Chips | $4.39 |
| Pureleaf Tea & Chips | $4.59 |
Every Jersey Mike's in Amherst, NY, cheapest first
| Restaurant | Original Italian | Basket | Index | Price level (national) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3030 Niagara Falls BoulevardAmherst, NY | $10.75 | $29.47 | 99 | $$$$$ |
| 8100 Transit RdAmherst, NY | $10.85 | $29.73 | 100 | $$$$$ |
| 1595 Niagara Falls BlvdAmherst, NY | $10.95 | $30.12 | 101 | $$$$$ |
Other fast food in Amherst, NY
- McDonald's, 3400 Sheridan Drive
- McDonald's, 1385 Niagara Falls Blvd
- McDonald's, 3120 Niagara Falls Blvd
- Wendy's, 3180 Niagara Falls Blvd
- Wendy's, 4050 Maple Rd.
- Taco Bell, 4258 Maple Road
- Kfc, 3962 Bailey Avenue
- Chipotle, 1643 Niagara Falls Blvd
- Chipotle, 3030 Niagara Blvd
- Firehouse Subs, 3336 Sheridan Dr.
- Five Guys, 8248 Transit Road
- Five Guys, 1551 Niagara Falls Blvd Suite 2
- Shake Shack, 1531 Niagara Falls Blvd Suite 300
- Arby's, 2945 Niagara Falls Blvd
- Dunkin', 3640 Main St
- Dunkin', 55 Cross Point Pkwy Suite 100
- Dunkin', 1355 Niagara Falls Blvd Delta Sonic
- Tim Hortons, University AT Buffalo (north C
- Tim Hortons, Univeristy AT Buffalo (north C
- Tim Hortons, 771 Wehrle Dr
- Tropical Smoothie Cafe, 3030 Niagara Falls Blvd
- Blaze Pizza, 1561 Niagara Falls Blvd., Suite 900
- Denny's, 3920 Maple Road
- Ihop, 4003 Maple Rd
- Red Robin, 4080 Maple Rd
- The Halal Guys, 1595 Niagara Falls Blvd. Suite 800
More Jersey Mike's prices
How these prices are measured
Every day we check the menu at every restaurant of each chain, through the same ordering app its customers use, and record each item's pickup price. Restaurants are compared on a basket of items every full-menu restaurant of that brand sells. An index of 100 is the brand's typical (median) restaurant in the country, so 95 means 5% cheaper and 110 means 10% pricier. Brands are only ever compared with themselves, never with each other.
Citing this data: Source: Drive Thru Index (https://drivethruindex.com/restaurants/us/ny/amherst/jersey-mikes-2345), prices checked 2026-10-05. You are welcome to quote any figure on this page.