Which state has the cheapest Tim Hortons Old Fashioned Plain?

Pennsylvania is the cheapest state for a Tim Hortons Old Fashioned Plain (typically $1.49) and New Jersey the most expensive ($1.99). Drive Thru Index, 2026-10-06.

Where is the cheapest Tim Hortons Old Fashioned Plain?

The cheapest Tim Hortons Old Fashioned Plain in the US is $1.05 at 1255 N Dixie HWY, Monroe, MI. (Drive Thru Index, 2026-10-06).

Tim Hortons Old Fashioned Plain price

Name: Tim Hortons Old Fashioned Plain Price (2026): by State and City | Drive Thru Index
Creator: Drive Thru Index
License: https://drivethruindex.com/insights#citing

A Tim Hortons Old Fashioned Plain costs $1.05 to $2.25 across 674 US Tim Hortons restaurants, typically $1.69.

Pickup prices at every Tim Hortons as of 6 October 2026.

Key findings

A Tim Hortons Old Fashioned Plain costs $1.05 to $2.25 across 674 US Tim Hortons restaurants, typically $1.69.
Pennsylvania is the cheapest state for a Tim Hortons Old Fashioned Plain (typically $1.49) and New Jersey the most expensive ($1.99).
The cheapest Tim Hortons Old Fashioned Plain in the US is $1.05 at 1255 N Dixie HWY, Monroe, MI.
Among cities with at least 3 Tim Hortons restaurants, Lancaster, OH has the cheapest Tim Hortons Old Fashioned Plain, typically $1.20.

Old Fashioned Plain price by state, cheapest first

Rank	State	Typical	Range	Index	Restaurants
1	Pennsylvania	$1.49	$1.49 to $1.79	88	17
2	Texas	$1.49	$1.45 to $1.79	88	13
3	Georgia	$1.49	$1.49 to $1.69	88	7
4	Maryland	$1.49	$1.49 to $1.49	88	1
5	Michigan	$1.59	$1.05 to $1.99	94	198
6	West Virginia	$1.59	$1.49 to $1.65	94	10
7	Maine	$1.65	$1.65 to $1.65	98	7
8	Kentucky	$1.65	$1.65 to $1.65	98	2
9	Indiana	$1.65	$1.65 to $1.65	98	1
10	Tennessee	$1.69	$1.69 to $1.69	100	7
11	Virginia	$1.69	$1.69 to $1.69	100	1
12	Delaware	$1.70	$1.70 to $1.70	101	1
13	New York	$1.79	$1.19 to $2.25	106	264
14	Florida	$1.79	$1.79 to $1.79	106	1
15	Ohio	$1.85	$1.49 to $2.03	109	129
16	New Jersey	$1.99	$1.69 to $2.15	118	15

Cheapest cities for a Old Fashioned Plain

City	Typical	Range	Restaurants
Lancaster, OH	$1.20	$1.20 to $1.20	3
Dearborn, MI	$1.45	$1.05 to $1.69	6
Westland, MI	$1.46	$1.39 to $1.46	3
Erie, PA	$1.49	$1.49 to $1.69	8
Warren, MI	$1.49	$1.49 to $1.49	7
Sterling Heights, MI	$1.49	$1.49 to $1.70	7
Houston, TX	$1.49	$1.49 to $1.69	5
Troy, MI	$1.49	$1.49 to $1.49	3
Madison Heights, MI	$1.49	$1.49 to $1.49	3
Taylor, MI	$1.51	$1.51 to $1.69	5

Priciest cities for a Old Fashioned Plain

City	Typical	Range	Restaurants
Farmington Hills, MI	$1.99	$1.79 to $1.99	3
Hempstead, NY	$1.99	$1.99 to $1.99	3
Ronkonkoma, NY	$1.99	$1.99 to $1.99	3
Staten Island, NY	$1.99	$1.99 to $1.99	4
Grove City, OH	$1.85	$1.85 to $1.85	3
Ann Arbor, MI	$1.85	$1.49 to $1.89	3
Westerville, OH	$1.85	$1.85 to $1.85	4
Hilliard, OH	$1.85	$1.85 to $1.85	4
Columbus, OH	$1.85	$1.75 to $1.85	31
North Tonawanda, NY	$1.79	$1.79 to $1.79	3

Cheapest Tim Hortons restaurants for a Old Fashioned Plain

Restaurant	Where	Price
1255 N Dixie HWY	Monroe, MI	$1.05
13661 Colson St	Dearborn, MI	$1.05
243 N River Ave	Holland, MI	$1.15
25744 US Route 11	Evans Mills, NY	$1.19
501 Mill St	Watertown, NY	$1.19

Priciest Tim Hortons restaurants for a Old Fashioned Plain

Restaurant	Where	Price
16 Ferris Ave	White Plains, NY	$2.25
93-40 Sutphin Blvd – Ground Floor - Jamaica Train Station	Jamaica, NY	$2.25
526 - Inman Ave	Colonia, NJ	$2.15
510 E Emmitt Ave	Waverly, OH	$2.03
819 W Jericho Turnpike	Smithtown, NY	$1.99

More Tim Hortons menu prices

Questions people ask

How much is a Tim Hortons Old Fashioned Plain?: As of 2026-10-06: A Tim Hortons Old Fashioned Plain costs $1.05 to $2.25 across 674 US Tim Hortons restaurants, typically $1.69.
Which state has the cheapest Tim Hortons Old Fashioned Plain?: Pennsylvania is the cheapest state for a Tim Hortons Old Fashioned Plain (typically $1.49) and New Jersey the most expensive ($1.99). Drive Thru Index, 2026-10-06.
Where is the cheapest Tim Hortons Old Fashioned Plain?: The cheapest Tim Hortons Old Fashioned Plain in the US is $1.05 at 1255 N Dixie HWY, Monroe, MI. (Drive Thru Index, 2026-10-06).

How these prices are measured

Every day we check the menu at every restaurant of each chain, through the same ordering app its customers use, and record each item's pickup price. Restaurants are compared on a basket of items every full-menu restaurant of that brand sells. An index of 100 is the brand's typical (median) restaurant in the country, so 95 means 5% cheaper and 110 means 10% pricier. Brands are only ever compared with themselves, never with each other.

Citing this data: Source: Drive Thru Index (https://drivethruindex.com/items/tim-hortons/old-fashioned-plain), prices checked 2026-10-06. You are welcome to quote any figure on this page.