Five Guys menu prices, 855 Montauk Highway, Shirley, NY
$$$$$ Cheaper than most Five Guys restaurants in the US
- A Hamburger costs $10.45 at this Five Guys (checked 2026-10-01).
- Its basket of 4 items (Hamburger, Hot Dog, Regular Fries, Regular Drink) costs $27.10, 5% below the typical Five Guys in the US.
855 Montauk Highway, Shirley, NY 11967. See it on the map
Full menu with prices (32 items)
Pickup prices from the Five Guys app, checked 2026-10-01. Items linked to their own page show how that price compares across the US.
| Item | Pickup |
|---|---|
| Burgers | |
| Bacon Burger | $11.45 |
| Bacon Cheeseburger | $12.05 |
| Cheeseburger | $11.15 |
| Hamburger | $10.45 |
| Little Bacon Burger | $9.45 |
| Little Bacon Cheeseburger | $10.15 |
| Little Cheeseburger | $9.15 |
| Little Hamburger | $8.45 |
| Drinks | |
| Bottled Coke | $3.25 |
| Bottled Coke Zero Sugar | $3.25 |
| Bottled Diet Coke | $3.25 |
| Bottled Simply Lemonade | $3.25 |
| Bottled Sprite | $3.25 |
| Bottled Water | $2.85 |
| Large Drink | $3.45 |
| Regular Drink | $3.15 |
| Fries | |
| Large Cajun Fries | $7.75 |
| Large Fries | $7.75 |
| Little Cajun Fries | $5.25 |
| Little Fries | $5.25 |
| Regular Cajun Fries | $6.55 |
| Regular Fries | $6.55 |
| Hot Dogs | |
| Bacon Cheese Dog | $8.65 |
| Bacon Dog | $7.95 |
| Cheese Dog | $7.65 |
| Hot Dog | $6.95 |
| Sandwiches | |
| Blt Sandwich | $8.05 |
| Grilled Cheese Sandwich | $6.75 |
| Patty Melt | $9.25 |
| Veggie Sandwich | $6.15 |
| Veggie Sandwich with Cheese | $6.85 |
| Shakes | |
| Milkshake | $6.15 |
Other fast food in Shirley, NY
- McDonald's, 971 Montauk Hwy
- Taco Bell, 551 William Floyd Parkway
- Kfc, 800 Montauk Highway
- Popeyes, 17 McGraw Street
- Chipotle, 800 Montauk Hwy
- Jersey Mike's, 800 Montauk Highway
- Sonic, 800 Montauk Highway
How these prices are measured
Every day we check the menu at every restaurant of each chain, through the same ordering app its customers use, and record each item's pickup price. Restaurants are compared on a basket of items every full-menu restaurant of that brand sells. An index of 100 is the brand's typical (median) restaurant in the country, so 95 means 5% cheaper and 110 means 10% pricier. Brands are only ever compared with themselves, never with each other.
Citing this data: Source: Drive Thru Index (https://drivethruindex.com/restaurants/five-guys/272333/shirley-ny), prices checked 2026-10-01. You are welcome to quote any figure on this page.