Fast food prices in Bay Shore, NY

Bay Shore, NY is the 55th cheapest of 89 New York cities we track for fast food (Drive Thru Index 108, 8% above the national typical price).

22 restaurants, prices as of 2026-10-08. See Bay Shore on the map

Key findings

• A McDonald's Big Mac typically costs $7.29 in Bay Shore, NY ($7.29 across 1 restaurants). McDonald's here is not enough restaurants to compare.
• A Burger King Whopper typically costs $7.24 in Bay Shore, NY ($6.59 to $7.89 across 2 restaurants). Burger King here is 9% above its typical price in the US.
• A Taco Bell Crunchwrap Supreme typically costs $6.89 in Bay Shore, NY ($6.89 across 1 restaurants). Taco Bell here is not enough restaurants to compare.
• A KFC Chicken Sandwich typically costs $5.49 in Bay Shore, NY ($5.49 across 1 restaurants). KFC here is not enough restaurants to compare.
• A Popeyes Classic Chicken Sandwich typically costs $5.79 in Bay Shore, NY ($5.79 across 1 restaurants). Popeyes here is not enough restaurants to compare.
• A Chipotle Chicken Burrito typically costs $10.50 in Bay Shore, NY ($10.50 across 1 restaurants). Chipotle here is not enough restaurants to compare.
• A Jersey Mike's Original Italian typically costs $11.29 in Bay Shore, NY ($11.29 across 1 restaurants). Jersey Mike's here is not enough restaurants to compare.
• A Five Guys Hamburger typically costs $10.45 in Bay Shore, NY ($10.45 across 1 restaurants). Five Guys here is not enough restaurants to compare.
• A Dunkin' Medium Original Blend typically costs $3.39 in Bay Shore, NY ($3.22 to $3.59 across 3 restaurants). Dunkin' here is 8% above its typical price in the US.
• A Wingstop 10 Classic Wings typically costs $15.59 in Bay Shore, NY ($15.59 across 1 restaurants). Wingstop here is not enough restaurants to compare.
• A Tim Hortons Medium Original Blend typically costs $2.99 in Bay Shore, NY ($2.99 across 1 restaurants). Tim Hortons here is not enough restaurants to compare.
• A Domino's Large Hand Tossed Pizza typically costs $12.99 in Bay Shore, NY ($12.99 across 1 restaurants). Domino's here is not enough restaurants to compare.
• A Tropical Smoothie Cafe Sunrise Sunset smoothie typically costs $8.69 in Bay Shore, NY ($8.69 across 1 restaurants). Tropical Smoothie Cafe here is not enough restaurants to compare.
• A Qdoba Chicken Burrito typically costs $10.85 in Bay Shore, NY ($10.85 across 1 restaurants). Qdoba here is not enough restaurants to compare.
• A Blaze Pizza Build Your Own Pizza typically costs $14.99 in Bay Shore, NY ($14.99 across 1 restaurants). Blaze Pizza here is not enough restaurants to compare.
• A Auntie Anne's Original Pretzel typically costs $5.39 in Bay Shore, NY ($5.39 across 1 restaurants). Auntie Anne's here is not enough restaurants to compare.
• A Carvel Small Sundae typically costs $5.59 in Bay Shore, NY ($5.59 across 1 restaurants). Carvel here is not enough restaurants to compare.
• A Chili's Big Smasher Burger typically costs $15.99 in Bay Shore, NY ($15.99 across 1 restaurants). Chili's here is not enough restaurants to compare.
• A IHOP Original Buttermilk Pancakes (Full Stack) typically costs $11.59 in Bay Shore, NY ($11.59 across 1 restaurants). IHOP here is not enough restaurants to compare.

Every brand in Bay Shore

Price history

Drive Thru Index has recorded these prices every day since 30 September 2026. Each figure is the typical (median) price across the brand's restaurants here on that day.

• A McDonald's Big Mac in Bay Shore, NY typically costs $7.29, unchanged from $7.29 on 30 September 2026.
• A Burger King Whopper in Bay Shore, NY typically costs $7.24, unchanged from $7.24 on 30 September 2026.
• A Taco Bell Crunchwrap Supreme in Bay Shore, NY typically costs $6.89, unchanged from $6.89 on 30 September 2026.
• A KFC Chicken Sandwich in Bay Shore, NY typically costs $5.49, unchanged from $5.49 on 30 September 2026.
• A Popeyes Classic Chicken Sandwich in Bay Shore, NY typically costs $5.79, unchanged from $5.79 on 30 September 2026.

Cheapest and priciest restaurant of each brand

Compared on the same basket of items at each restaurant of the brand. The gap is how much more the priciest charges for that basket.

Every restaurant in Bay Shore, NY

Each restaurant links to its full menu with prices.

McDonald's

Burger King

Taco Bell

KFC

Popeyes

Chipotle

Jersey Mike's

Five Guys

Dunkin'

Wingstop

Tim Hortons

Domino's

Tropical Smoothie Cafe

Qdoba

Blaze Pizza

Auntie Anne's

Carvel

Chili's

IHOP

Nearby in New York

• New York
• Brooklyn
• Bronx
• Rochester
• Staten Island
• Buffalo
• Syracuse
• Jamaica
• Albany
• Yonkers
• Flushing
• Niagara Falls

Questions people ask

How much is a McDonald's Big Mac in Bay Shore, NY?

As of 2026-10-08, a Big Mac costs $7.29 at 1 McDonald's restaurants in Bay Shore, NY, typically $7.29.

How much is a Burger King Whopper in Bay Shore, NY?

As of 2026-10-08, a Whopper costs $6.59 to $7.89 at 2 Burger King restaurants in Bay Shore, NY, typically $7.24.

How much is a Taco Bell Crunchwrap Supreme in Bay Shore, NY?

As of 2026-10-08, a Crunchwrap Supreme costs $6.89 at 1 Taco Bell restaurants in Bay Shore, NY, typically $6.89.

How much is a KFC Chicken Sandwich in Bay Shore, NY?

As of 2026-10-08, a Chicken Sandwich costs $5.49 at 1 KFC restaurants in Bay Shore, NY, typically $5.49.

How much is a Popeyes Classic Chicken Sandwich in Bay Shore, NY?

As of 2026-10-08, a Classic Chicken Sandwich costs $5.79 at 1 Popeyes restaurants in Bay Shore, NY, typically $5.79.

How much is a Chipotle Chicken Burrito in Bay Shore, NY?

As of 2026-10-08, a Chicken Burrito costs $10.50 at 1 Chipotle restaurants in Bay Shore, NY, typically $10.50.

How much is a Jersey Mike's Original Italian in Bay Shore, NY?

As of 2026-10-08, a Original Italian costs $11.29 at 1 Jersey Mike's restaurants in Bay Shore, NY, typically $11.29.

How much is a Five Guys Hamburger in Bay Shore, NY?

As of 2026-10-08, a Hamburger costs $10.45 at 1 Five Guys restaurants in Bay Shore, NY, typically $10.45.

How much is a Dunkin' Medium Original Blend in Bay Shore, NY?

As of 2026-10-08, a Medium Original Blend costs $3.22 to $3.59 at 3 Dunkin' restaurants in Bay Shore, NY, typically $3.39.

Where is the cheapest Dunkin' in Bay Shore, NY?

The cheapest Dunkin' in Bay Shore, NY is at 19 Bay Shore Rd, Bay Shore, comparing the same basket at 3 restaurants (Drive Thru Index, 2026-10-08).

How much is a Wingstop 10 Classic Wings in Bay Shore, NY?

As of 2026-10-08, a 10 Classic Wings costs $15.59 at 1 Wingstop restaurants in Bay Shore, NY, typically $15.59.

How much is a Tim Hortons Medium Original Blend in Bay Shore, NY?

As of 2026-10-08, a Medium Original Blend costs $2.99 at 1 Tim Hortons restaurants in Bay Shore, NY, typically $2.99.

How much is a Domino's Large Hand Tossed Pizza in Bay Shore, NY?

As of 2026-10-08, a Large Hand Tossed Pizza costs $12.99 at 1 Domino's restaurants in Bay Shore, NY, typically $12.99.

How much is a Tropical Smoothie Cafe Sunrise Sunset smoothie in Bay Shore, NY?

As of 2026-10-08, a Sunrise Sunset smoothie costs $8.69 at 1 Tropical Smoothie Cafe restaurants in Bay Shore, NY, typically $8.69.

How much is a Qdoba Chicken Burrito in Bay Shore, NY?

As of 2026-10-08, a Chicken Burrito costs $10.85 at 1 Qdoba restaurants in Bay Shore, NY, typically $10.85.

How much is a Blaze Pizza Build Your Own Pizza in Bay Shore, NY?

As of 2026-10-08, a Build Your Own Pizza costs $14.99 at 1 Blaze Pizza restaurants in Bay Shore, NY, typically $14.99.

How much is a Auntie Anne's Original Pretzel in Bay Shore, NY?

As of 2026-10-08, a Original Pretzel costs $5.39 at 1 Auntie Anne's restaurants in Bay Shore, NY, typically $5.39.

How much is a Carvel Small Sundae in Bay Shore, NY?

As of 2026-10-08, a Small Sundae costs $5.59 at 1 Carvel restaurants in Bay Shore, NY, typically $5.59.

How much is a Chili's Big Smasher Burger in Bay Shore, NY?

As of 2026-10-08, a Big Smasher Burger costs $15.99 at 1 Chili's restaurants in Bay Shore, NY, typically $15.99.

How much is a IHOP Original Buttermilk Pancakes (Full Stack) in Bay Shore, NY?

As of 2026-10-08, a Original Buttermilk Pancakes (Full Stack) costs $11.59 at 1 IHOP restaurants in Bay Shore, NY, typically $11.59.

Has the price of a McDonald's Big Mac in Bay Shore, NY gone up?

A McDonald's Big Mac in Bay Shore, NY typically costs $7.29, unchanged from $7.29 on 30 September 2026. (Drive Thru Index, 2026-10-08).

Has the price of a Burger King Whopper in Bay Shore, NY gone up?

A Burger King Whopper in Bay Shore, NY typically costs $7.24, unchanged from $7.24 on 30 September 2026. (Drive Thru Index, 2026-10-08).

Has the price of a Taco Bell Crunchwrap Supreme in Bay Shore, NY gone up?

A Taco Bell Crunchwrap Supreme in Bay Shore, NY typically costs $6.89, unchanged from $6.89 on 30 September 2026. (Drive Thru Index, 2026-10-08).

Has the price of a KFC Chicken Sandwich in Bay Shore, NY gone up?

A KFC Chicken Sandwich in Bay Shore, NY typically costs $5.49, unchanged from $5.49 on 30 September 2026. (Drive Thru Index, 2026-10-08).

Has the price of a Popeyes Classic Chicken Sandwich in Bay Shore, NY gone up?

A Popeyes Classic Chicken Sandwich in Bay Shore, NY typically costs $5.79, unchanged from $5.79 on 30 September 2026. (Drive Thru Index, 2026-10-08).

How these prices are measured

Every day we check the menu at every restaurant of each chain, through the same ordering app its customers use, and record each item's pickup price. Restaurants are compared on a basket of items every full-menu restaurant of that brand sells. An index of 100 is the brand's typical (median) restaurant in the country, so 95 means 5% cheaper and 110 means 10% pricier. Brands are only ever compared with themselves, never with each other.

Citing this data: Source: Drive Thru Index (https://drivethruindex.com/prices/new-york/bay-shore), prices checked 2026-10-08. You are welcome to quote any figure on this page.