How much is a Jersey Mike's Original Italian in New Jersey?

As of 2026-10-03, a Original Italian costs $8.25 to $13.85 at 148 Jersey Mike's restaurants in New Jersey, typically $11.50.

Where is the cheapest Jersey Mike's in New Jersey?

The cheapest Jersey Mike's in New Jersey is at 235 Prospect Ave, West Orange, comparing the same basket at 131 restaurants (Drive Thru Index, 2026-10-03).

Jersey Mike's prices in New Jersey

Name: Jersey Mike's Prices in New Jersey (2026) | Drive Thru Index
Creator: Drive Thru Index
License: https://drivethruindex.com/insights#citing

148 Jersey Mike's restaurants in New Jersey, prices checked 2026-10-03.

Key findings

A Jersey Mike's Original Italian typically costs $11.50 in New Jersey ($8.25 to $13.85 across 148 restaurants). Jersey Mike's here is 4% above its typical price in the US.

The scoop

Newark stacks the tallest sub bill
Jersey Mike’s swings 36% across 132 NJ restaurants. The basket runs from $29.23 in Bloomfield, NJ to $39.89 in Newark, NJ.

That Italian has a wide Jersey range
The Regular The Original Italian goes from $10.75 to $13.85 around the state. At the endpoints named here, it is $10.85 in Bloomfield, NJ and $13.85 in Newark, NJ.

NJ sits on the pricier side
Jersey Mike’s median basket in NJ is $30.94. That is 4% above the national typical price, ranking 39 of 50 states where 1 = cheapest.

Turnpike stop lands among priciest
One travel-flavoured outlier pops up among the higher Jersey Mike’s bills. A turnpike site in Ramsey, NJ posts a $32.57 basket.

Every Jersey Mike's in New Jersey, by town

Each restaurant links to its full menu with prices. A town with its own page links to it, where every brand there is compared.

City	Restaurants	Typical Original Italian	Restaurant
Atlantic Highlands	1	$10.95	7 Bayshore Plaza
Barnegat	1	$11.50	770d-a Lighthouse Drive
Bayonne	1	$11.75	901 Bayonne Crossing Way
Bayville	1	$11.35	333 Atlantic City Blvd.
Belmar	2	$11.35	500 Main Street · 1001 Ocean Avenue
Bernardsville	1	$10.85	80 Morristown Road
Bloomfield	1	$10.85	224 Bloomfield Avenue
Boonton	1	$10.95	534 Myrtle Avenue
Bordentown	1	$11.50	266 Dunns Mill Road
Brick	3	$11.50	602 Mantoloking Road · all 3 in Brick
Budd Lake	1	$10.95	100 Route 46 West
Burlington	1	$10.75	1817 Mt Holly Road
Cape May Court House	1	$10.75	11 Court House South Dennis Road
Chatham	1	$11.50	641 Shunpike Road
Cherry Hill	1	$11.50	512 Haddonfield Road
Chester	1	$10.95	390 US Highway 206
Cinnaminson	1	$11.50	127 L Rt. 130
Clark	1	$11.50	301 Central Avenue
Cliffwood	1	$10.95	311 Route 35
Clifton	1	$11.50	850 Route 3 West
Clinton	1	$10.95	61 Walmart Plaza
Cresskill	1	$11.75	1 Union Ave.
Delran	1	$11.35	1330 Fairview Boulevard
Denville	1	$11.50	3130 Route 10 West
Dover	1	$11.50	437 US Highway 46
East Brunswick	1	$11.50	285 Route 18 S.
East Rutherford	1	$11.50	50 Route 17 North
East Windsor	1	$10.95	319 Route 130
Edgewater	1	$11.75	725 River Road
Elizabeth	1	$11.75	505 North Broad Street
Emerson	1	$11.75	464 Kinderkamack Road.
Englewood	1	$11.50	61 Nathaniel Place
Ewing	1	$10.95	400 Main Blvd East
Fair Lawn	1	$11.50	3120 Promenade Blvd.
Farmingdale	1	$10.95	1175 Route 33
Flanders	1	$11.50	293 Route 206
Flemington	1	$10.95	75 Reaville Avenue
Florham Park	1	$10.95	182 Ridgedale Ave.
Forked River	1	$11.35	1 Lacey Road
Fort Lee	1	$11.75	2151 Lemoine Avenue
Freehold	1	$10.95	3528 Route 9 South
Glassboro	1	$8.25	201 Mullica Hill Road
Hackensack	1	$11.75	120 River Street
Hackettstown	1	$10.75	1885 Rt 57
Hainesport	1	$11.50	1520 Route 38
Hamilton	1	$11.35	620 Marketplace Blvd.
Hamilton Square	1	$10.95	950 Hwy. 33
Hillsborough	1	$10.75	706 Route 206 D
Hoboken	1	$11.75	202 Hudson Street
Holmdel	1	$10.95	2145 State Route 35
Howell	1	$10.75	3950 Route 9 and Aldrich Road
Jackson	2	$10.95	2275 West County Line Road · all 2 in Jackson
Kearny	1	$11.40	190 Passaic Avenue
Lakewood	1	$10.85	1195 Route 70
Lavallette	1	$11.80	604 Grand Central
Lawrence	1	$10.75	2495 Brunswick Pike
Lawrenceville	1	$8.95	The Bart Luedeke Center
Lincoln Park	1	$10.75	275 Comly Road
Lincroft	1	$11.50	728 Newman Springs Road
Linden	1	$11.50	683 W. Edgar Road
Little Egg Harbor	1	$11.50	418 Rt. 9 South
Little Ferry	1	$11.50	269 Route 46 West
Long Branch	1	$10.95	444 Ocean Blvd North
Lyndhurst	1	$11.40	548 New York Avenue
Manahawkin	1	$11.50	25 South Main Street
Manasquan	2	$10.95	2627 Highway 70 · all 2 in Manasquan
Marlton	1	$11.50	908 Rt. 73 North
Matawan	1	$10.95	251 Main Street
Mays Landing	1	$10.75	4300 Black Horse Pike
Metuchen	1	$11.75	349 Lake Avenue
Middletown	1	$10.95	1209 Route 35
Millville	1	$11.50	2190 N 2nd Street
Montclair	1	$9.25	1 Normal Avenue
Montvale	1	$11.95	12 Chestnut Ridge Road
Moorestown	1	$11.50	1624 Nixon Dr.
Morganville	1	$10.85	450 Union Hill Rd.
Morristown	1	$10.95	191 East Hanover Ave
Mt. Laurel	1	$11.50	10 Centerton Road
Neptune	2	$10.95	2305 State Highway 66 · all 2 in Neptune
New Brunswick	1	$10.85	44 College Ave
New Providence	1	$11.50	1260 Springfield Ave.
Newark	3	$12.85	265 Market Street · all 3 in Newark
Newton	1	$11.50	13 Hampton House Road
North Bergen	1	$11.50	2100 88th Street
North Haledon	1	$11.50	475 High Mountain Road
Northvale	1	$11.50	254c Livingston Street
Oakhurst	1	$10.95	2100 Hwy 35
Paramus	1	$11.75	305 Route 17 South
Park Ridge	1	$11.95	185 Kinderkamack Road
Parlin	1	$10.95	1068 Rt. 9 South
Parsippany	1	$10.95	317 Smith Rd.
Piscataway	1	$10.85	1322 Centennial Avenue
Point Pleasant	1	$10.85	2600 Bridge Avenue
Point Pleasant Beach	1	$10.85	901 Richmond Avenue
Pompton Plains	1	$11.50	500 Rt. 23
Princeton	1	$10.95	3495 Highway 1 South
Ramsey	1	$11.95	557 North Franklin Turnpike
Raritan	1	$10.85	300 Route 202 South
Red Bank	1	$11.94	100 Water Street
Ridgewood	1	$11.95	305 E Ridgewood Ave
River Edge	1	$11.75	1045 Main Street
Rochelle Park	1	$11.75	60 Essex St.
Roseland	1	$11.50	35 Eisenhower Parkway
Secaucus	1	$11.50	200 Mill Creek Drive
Sewell	1	$10.85	415 Egg Harbor Road
Shrewsbury	1	$11.25	10 Shrewsbury Plaza
Sicklerville	1	$10.85	3421 Black Horse Pike
Silverton	1	$11.50	1840 Hooper Avenue
Skillman	1	$11.50	1320 Van Horne Road
Somerset	2	$10.80	1165 Route 27 · all 2 in Somerset
South Orange	1	$8.65	400 S.Orange Avenue
Sparta	1	$11.50	10 North Village Blvd.
Spotswood	1	$11.75	93 Old Stage Road
Springfield	1	$11.75	201 Route 22
Succasunna	1	$11.50	275 State Route 10 E
Toms River	4	$11.50	1362 Hooper Avenue · all 4 in Toms River
Totowa	1	$11.50	160 Union Blvd
Union	2	$10.00	1350 Galloping Hill Rd · all 2 in Union
Voorhees	1	$11.50	910 Haddonfield-Berlin Rd.
Wall	1	$10.95	1933 Highway 35 & Allaire Road
Wanaque (Wanaque	1	$11.50	1353 Ringwood Ave
Warren	1	$11.75	177 Washington Valley Rd.
Washington	1	$10.95	5 Club House Drive
Wayne	2	$11.50	57 Rt. 23 · all 2 in Wayne
West Caldwell	1	$11.50	775 Bloomfield Ave
West Long Branch	2	$9.60	175 Monmouth Road · all 2 in West Long Branch
West Orange	1	$10.85	235 Prospect Ave
West Windsor	1	$10.95	43 Princeton Hightstown Road
Whippany	1	$11.50	456 Route 10
White House Station (White Station)	1	$10.85	531 Us-22
Whiting	1	$11.50	420 Lacey Road
Woodbridge	1	$11.75	899 B St. Georges Avenue
Wyckoff	1	$11.95	300 Godwin Ave.

More prices

Questions people ask

How much is a Jersey Mike's Original Italian in New Jersey?: As of 2026-10-03, a Original Italian costs $8.25 to $13.85 at 148 Jersey Mike's restaurants in New Jersey, typically $11.50.
Where is the cheapest Jersey Mike's in New Jersey?: The cheapest Jersey Mike's in New Jersey is at 235 Prospect Ave, West Orange, comparing the same basket at 131 restaurants (Drive Thru Index, 2026-10-03).

How these prices are measured

Every day we check the menu at every restaurant of each chain, through the same ordering app its customers use, and record each item's pickup price. Restaurants are compared on a basket of items every full-menu restaurant of that brand sells. An index of 100 is the brand's typical (median) restaurant in the country, so 95 means 5% cheaper and 110 means 10% pricier. Brands are only ever compared with themselves, never with each other.

Citing this data: Source: Drive Thru Index (https://drivethruindex.com/brands/jersey-mikes/new-jersey), prices checked 2026-10-03. You are welcome to quote any figure on this page.