How much is a Jersey Mike's Original Italian in Indiana?

As of 2026-10-03, a Original Italian costs $9.45 to $11.45 at 40 Jersey Mike's restaurants in Indiana, typically $10.80.

Where is the cheapest Jersey Mike's in Indiana?

The cheapest Jersey Mike's in Indiana is at 5025 E. 82nd Street, Indianapolis, comparing the same basket at 38 restaurants (Drive Thru Index, 2026-10-03).

Jersey Mike's prices in Indiana

Name: Jersey Mike's Prices in Indiana (2026) | Drive Thru Index
Creator: Drive Thru Index
License: https://drivethruindex.com/insights#citing

40 Jersey Mike's restaurants in Indiana, prices checked 2026-10-03.

Key findings

A Jersey Mike's Original Italian typically costs $10.80 in Indiana ($9.45 to $11.45 across 40 restaurants). Jersey Mike's here is 1% below its typical price in the US.

The scoop

Indiana lands in the bargain tier
Jersey Mike's in IN ranks 7 of 50 states, where 1 = cheapest. The median basket is $29.57, sitting 1% below the national typical price.

A 19% sub spread
Across 38 Jersey Mike's stores compared, the basket spread is 19%. Indianapolis, IN is the low end at $26.32, while Terre Haute, IN tops the state at $31.37.

Original Italian swings by town
The Regular The Original Italian runs from $9.95 to $11.45 in IN. It is $9.95 in Indianapolis, IN and $11.45 in Terre Haute, IN.

Every Jersey Mike's in Indiana, by town

Each restaurant links to its full menu with prices. A town with its own page links to it, where every brand there is compared.

City	Restaurants	Typical Original Italian	Restaurant
Anderson	1	$10.80	4770 S. Scatterfield Road
Angola	1	$10.85	1400 North Wayne Street
Auburn	1	$10.85	523 West 7th Street
Avon	1	$10.80	10445 U.s. Route 36
Bloomington	1	$10.80	2618 East 10th Street
Carmel	1	$10.85	2271 Pointe Parkway
Charlestown	1	$10.85	9401 County Road 403
Clarksville	1	$10.80	1305 Veterans Parkway
Columbus	1	$10.80	1449 N. National Road
Crown Point	1	$9.45	10714 Broadway
Evansville	1	$10.25	939 N Burkhardt Rd
Fort Wayne	2	$10.85	10020 Lima Road · all 2 in Fort Wayne
Greenfield	2	$10.82	2776 North 600 West · all 2 in Greenfield
Greensburg	1	$10.80	404 East Freeland Road
Greenwood	1	$10.80	1675 W Smith Valley Rd
Indianapolis	3	$10.80	5025 E. 82nd Street · all 3 in Indianapolis
Jeffersonville	1	$10.85	5530 East Hwy. 62
La Porte	1	$11.15	111 North Madison Street
Lafayette	1	$10.85	210 South Creasy Lane
Marion	1	$10.80	3117 S Western Avenue
Merrillville	1	$10.85	2871 E. 81st Avenue
Mishawaka	1	$10.95	5718 N. Main Street
Muncie	1	$10.80	236 W McGalliard Road
Munster	1	$10.75	8153 Calumet Avenue
New Albany	1	$10.80	404 W Daisy Lane
Newburgh	1	$10.25	8850 High Pointe Drive
Noblesville	2	$10.85	6165 Promenade Shops Boulevard · all 2 in Noblesville
Portage	1	$10.85	5976 US Highway 6
Schererville	2	$10.75	37 U.s. Highway 41 · all 2 in Schererville
South Bend	1	$10.95	315 West Ireland Road
Terre Haute	1	$11.45	3420b S. US Hwy 41
West Lafayette	1	$10.25	401 N. Russell Street
Westfield	1	$10.75	124 West Spring Mill Point Drive
Zionsville	1	$10.85	10725 N. Michigan Rd.

More prices

Questions people ask

How much is a Jersey Mike's Original Italian in Indiana?: As of 2026-10-03, a Original Italian costs $9.45 to $11.45 at 40 Jersey Mike's restaurants in Indiana, typically $10.80.
Where is the cheapest Jersey Mike's in Indiana?: The cheapest Jersey Mike's in Indiana is at 5025 E. 82nd Street, Indianapolis, comparing the same basket at 38 restaurants (Drive Thru Index, 2026-10-03).

How these prices are measured

Every day we check the menu at every restaurant of each chain, through the same ordering app its customers use, and record each item's pickup price. Restaurants are compared on a basket of items every full-menu restaurant of that brand sells. An index of 100 is the brand's typical (median) restaurant in the country, so 95 means 5% cheaper and 110 means 10% pricier. Brands are only ever compared with themselves, never with each other.

Citing this data: Source: Drive Thru Index (https://drivethruindex.com/brands/jersey-mikes/indiana), prices checked 2026-10-03. You are welcome to quote any figure on this page.